For
two weeks, we’ve heard trial testimony and seen evidence of the events
that occurred on August 25, 2020 — the night that Kyle Rittenhouse shot
and killed two people and injured another during a Black Lives Matter
protest in Kenosha, Wisconsin. While Rittenhouse was not held
accountable, he was not the only one whose conduct on that deadly night
should be scrutinized. The actions — and inaction — of the Kenosha
Police Department and the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department in the
preceding 72 hours played a critical part in the tragic events that took
place.
As we reflect on that night, we must remember what ignited these
protests. Two months after the murder of George Floyd, on August 23,
2020, Kenosha Police shot a Black man, Jacob Blake, in the back multiple
times, paralyzing him. Faced with this latest manifestation of law
enforcement’s systemic mistreatment and disregard for the lives of Black
and Brown people, people took to the streets of Kenosha. Kenosha County
Sheriff David Beth oversaw law enforcement’s response to these
protests, including the coordination of over 40 local, state, and
federal agencies.
The day after Kenosha Police shot Mr. Blake, former city alderman and
self-proclaimed commander of the Kenosha Guard Kevin Mathewson wrote a
racially charged “call to action” inviting armed civilians to protect
Kenosha from “evil thugs” the following day. The comments on his
Facebook invitation, corresponding Reddit threads, and Infowars
degenerated into racist threats to kill and maim protestors.
On the night of August 25, law enforcement not only failed to protect
protestors calling for police accountability and more humane treatment
of Black people, but actively put them in harm’s way. Officers enabled
and encouraged predominantly white, right-wing armed civilians and
militia groups that night, creating a situation in which tensions
escalated and people were killed.
Following the violence in Kenosha, an investigative team at the ACLU
filed approximately 40 public records requests to local, state, and
federal law enforcement agencies; reviewed more than 800 records and 50
hours of video footage; and conducted over 40 in-depth interviews with
community members to better understand what happened in Kenosha and how
we can avoid these tragedies in the future. Here is what we found:
Kenosha law enforcement was aware of the threats that these
armed civilians and militia groups posed to protestors exercising their
First Amendment rights. Mathewson asked Sheriff Beth and Kenosha Police Chief David Miskinis to deputize
these armed civilians and militia groups, noting that more than 3,000
people accepted the online invitation to “protect” the city. In addition
to this correspondence, community members in Kenosha contacted law
enforcement with concerns for their safety after reading this online vitriol. Meanwhile, the Department of Homeland Security
told local law enforcement that the Boogaloo Bois, a right-wing group
with a history of violence, were planning an event in Kenosha on August
24. The Federal Bureau of Investigation also warned that the conflicting
ideologies of protestors and these armed civilians and militia groups
could “potentially be a flashpoint for violence” the next day.
Despite the obvious safety threats, law enforcement embraced the incendiary presence of armed civilians and militia groups. In a widely seen video, law enforcement thanked and even offered water
to the armed civilians and militia groups attending the protests, as
they instructed those protesting police brutality to leave. In text
messages retrieved through our public records requests, after someone
circulated a video of the Rittenhouse shootings, a Waukesha County
Sheriff’s Department officer commented “nice video” in a message to colleagues and added that he was “[l]istening to gunfire. Such a nice night.”
In fact, it appears Kenosha law enforcement coordinated an
effort to push protestors south on Sheridan Road, towards armed
civilians and militia groups. Ryan Thomas Balch, an armed
civilian affiliated with the Boogaloo Bois, was recorded saying on the
night of the shootings, “Do you know what the cops told us today? They
were like, ‘We’re gonna push them down by you, because you can deal with
them, and then we’re gonna leave.’” In an August 26, 2020 written statement,
Balch added, “K[enosha] P[olice] D[epartment] made a conscious decision
to abandon the people of Kenosha to people they felt justified in using
machines and weapons of war against. And were going to piss them off
and drive them at us and let the chips fall where they may.”
The Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department, led by Sheriff Beth,
commanded law enforcement agencies to clear Civic Center Park and push
protestors south towards the danger that lay multiple blocks from the
park at the intersection of 60th and Sheridan. Multiple law enforcement
officers documented their knowledge that armed civilians and militia
members were concentrated in that direction, near 60th and Sheridan.
Officers from various law enforcement agencies described the use of
armored vehicles, foam bullets, tear gas, and flash bangs to herd
protestors from the park toward the intersection, and to prevent the
return of protestors to the park. After pushing the protestors south for
over an hour, Kenosha law enforcement took a strategically timed break,
consistent with Balch’s description. These efforts were well documented in the records our investigative team obtained:
- 9:43 pm: The Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department documented “gas
being deployed in front of the courthouse, goal to push crowd south.”
- 10:32 pm: Kenosha Police Department dispatched patrol to 58th and 8th to “keep crowd moving south on Sheridan.”
- 10:40 pm: Three bearcats moved south from 56th on Sheridan.
- 10:44 pm: Law enforcement continued to push protestors down the road.
- 10:57 pm: Law enforcement took a break.
- 11:12 pm: The Waukesha County Sheriff’s Department reported that
protestors “have been pushed south and we are holding our position at
the park.”
- 11:40 pm: Bearcats from Racine, Walworth, Waukesha, and Sauk
Counties held protestors at 60th and Sheridan, and noted a loud crowd at
the gas station.
- 11:44 pm: An Oneida County bearcat moved to 60th and Sheridan.
- 11:50 pm: Rittenhouse shootings begin at 63rd and Sheridan.
The West Allis Police Department also described its actions:
At the request of tactical command, the armored vehicles and crowd
control [o]fficers would direct the protestors south and hold or move
the protestors south and back away north. Tactical command requested
several times for this process to occur which led to the protestors
being directed as far south as 60th St. & Sheridan.
Three important lessons emerge from this tragedy.
First, entrenched racism contributed to the events that unfolded.
Make no mistake, the shooting of Jacob Blake and the related protests
and fatalities stem from the deep-seated white supremacy that pervades
our criminal legal system. Police officers brutalizing people of color
who are protesting that very brutality and leaving people of color and
their supporters at the mercy of armed white vigilantes is a pattern
that recalls the origin of American police in slave patrols. These
patrols sought to capture and return formerly enslaved people to the
violence of enslavement, and their later connections to white
supremacist agitation during the Civil Rights movement are echoed in the
violence seen in Kenosha. In today’s world, Black and Brown people are
not only targeted by police and frequently treated as presumptively
guilty, but white people brandishing weapons of war are given the
benefit of the doubt and even encouraged by officers of those same
police agencies.
Second, law enforcement must not be permitted to weaponize the
presence of armed civilians and militia. Jacob Blake’s shooting and the
subsequent tragic, fatal shootings by Rittenhouse should usher in a
significant wave of change, not only in Wisconsin but across the nation.
Kenosha is not even the latest example of this pattern of police
ignoring (at best) or facilitating (at worst) white mob violence:
Following the January 6 insurrection, it was revealed that over 30 off-duty police officers
attended the rally, and several joined the mob that stormed the
Capitol. We must reexamine the roles and powers of police in American
society, and listen to the communities of color in Kenosha and elsewhere
that are calling for new approaches to public safety that protect all
people, regardless of the color of their skin.
Finally, more officers and weapons do not increase safety.
Law enforcement should play no role in protests, unless it is to
protect our First Amendment rights, and they should not use violence to
control the crowd or silence those they disagree with. Beyond the
context of protests, there is little evidence that police effectively prevent or reduce violence, while there are many alternatives to policing that do make communities safer.
As our investigation illustrates, approximately 40 local, state, and
federal law enforcement agencies responded to the protests in Kenosha,
utilizing various forms of force against protestors. This massive show
of force failed to keep people safe — and in fact facilitated grave harm
by pushing protesters into close proximity with Kyle Rittenhouse and
other armed white civilians. The violence that night is a further
reminder that well-resourced law enforcement agencies are failing to
protect and even harming the communities they are sworn to serve. It’s
time to acknowledge this failure and invest in measures that actually keep communities safe.
