Update: For those of you not pretending to think like a Republican primary voter, Salon has two analyses, and here's Nichols' take:
- What you missed while watching "Chad Vader" by Michael Scherer
- The godawful GOP debate by Walter Shapiro
- Out-Tancredoing Tancredo at GOP's Anti-Immigrant Debate by John Nichols
As a libertarian liberal watching the GOP's CNN/YouTube debate trying to think as a Republican primary voter, here are some impressions:
Rudy Giuliani - Did nothing to hurt himself. Seems unafraid to take unpopular positions, but reeks of the City. Still standing after immigration grilling. Not great on today's Politico's Billing-the-city piece. Third place.
Mike Huckabee - Impressive, witty, and religious; appears in sharper command of issues than in previous weeks. Co-winner.
Rep. Duncan Hunter - Unremarkable
Sen. John McCain - Slow start, but took off after torture question and demonstrated the command and clarity that made McCain an early front-runner. Second place.
Rep. Ron Paul - Decisive, earnest, anti-war and pro-vet. This guy is popular with veterans and is raising one hell of a lot of money. And the Iraq War is not nearly as popular with GOP voters as many pretend. GOP better find a way to stop this guy. Co-winner.
Mitt Romney - Indecisive, insincere and slick; unsteady, especially on the gays-in-the-military and torture questions. Big loser.
Rep. Tom Tancredo - Unremarkable
Fred Thompson - Listless, uninspired, and fading fast. Big loser.
The first primary is weeks away. And debates, mini-scandals and talking heads now matter. Campaign operatives are losing hair, I assure you.
###
- What you missed while watching "Chad Vader" by Michael Scherer
- The godawful GOP debate by Walter Shapiro
- Out-Tancredoing Tancredo at GOP's Anti-Immigrant Debate by John Nichols
As a libertarian liberal watching the GOP's CNN/YouTube debate trying to think as a Republican primary voter, here are some impressions:
Rudy Giuliani - Did nothing to hurt himself. Seems unafraid to take unpopular positions, but reeks of the City. Still standing after immigration grilling. Not great on today's Politico's Billing-the-city piece. Third place.
Mike Huckabee - Impressive, witty, and religious; appears in sharper command of issues than in previous weeks. Co-winner.
Rep. Duncan Hunter - Unremarkable
Sen. John McCain - Slow start, but took off after torture question and demonstrated the command and clarity that made McCain an early front-runner. Second place.
Rep. Ron Paul - Decisive, earnest, anti-war and pro-vet. This guy is popular with veterans and is raising one hell of a lot of money. And the Iraq War is not nearly as popular with GOP voters as many pretend. GOP better find a way to stop this guy. Co-winner.
Mitt Romney - Indecisive, insincere and slick; unsteady, especially on the gays-in-the-military and torture questions. Big loser.
Rep. Tom Tancredo - Unremarkable
Fred Thompson - Listless, uninspired, and fading fast. Big loser.
The first primary is weeks away. And debates, mini-scandals and talking heads now matter. Campaign operatives are losing hair, I assure you.
###
