Showing posts with label Kevin Kennedy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kevin Kennedy. Show all posts

Dec 20, 2014

State Journal's Dee Halls Blows John Doe-GAB Piece

Wisconsin John Doe Statute
Update: Further knockdown of Wisconsin discredited rightwinger, subject of State Journal stenography. From Marley, Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel:
"The attorney for the state's ethics and elections board on Saturday said he will soon file court papers disputing claims that the agency had violated Wisconsin laws in pursing a campaign finance investigation of Gov. Scott Walker's campaign and conservative groups."

The Government Accountability Board will present evidence that 'will refute and disprove specific allegations as well as the general hyperbole of the plaintiff's complaint,' said a statement from the board's attorney, Paul Schwarzenbart."
---
What is the Wisconsin State Journal (Madison, Wisconsin) newsroom doing to its reporter Dee Hall?

Hall is typically a solid and occasionally brilliant journalist but errs and misreports badly in today's Page One piece, "GAB didn't OK secret inquiry, records say."

Hall's reporting is uninformed, contrived and is constructed in the manner of a GOP operative's.

In fairness to Hall, uninformed reporting in Wisconsin on the John Doe probes of criminality associated with Scott Walker and his former staff is on a par of the low-grade journalism put out by Gannett Co. and Wisconsin's rightwing propaganda mill, the Wisconsin Reporter and other GOP organs.

The piece reports on the release of Government Accountability Board (GAB) documents, ordered by a Waukesha County judge at the request of rightwinger Eric O'Keefe of the extremist group, Wisconsin Club for Growth.

Writes Hall:
The state Government Accountability Board’s top officials proceeded with a secret probe into coordination between Gov. Scott Walker’s campaign and conservative political groups for months without authorization from the six retired judges who run the board, court records unsealed Friday allege.

The documents filed by a target of the investigation also allege that the board voted to end its involvement in the probe in July but that staff continued to work on it.

The records add ammunition to Republicans in the state Legislature seeking to overhaul or abolish Wisconsin’s elections and ethics watchdog agency.

Some corrections:

Target

There are no targets (ala federal grand juries and many other state grand jury systems) in Wisconsin John Doe proceedings until a probe determines individual(s) are to be criminally charged and served with a probable cause warrant.

Wisconsin John Doe probes investigate if and by whom crimes may have been committed when conflicts of interest, practical difficulties (such as stonewalling) and protection of privacy is judged imperative by a district attorney(s) and a supervising judge, per Wisconsin statute, who determine that reasonable suspicion of criminality merit further investigation in the above circumstances.

For Hall to refer to Mr. O'Keefe as a "target of the investigation" is an error in reporting, and one which furthers the GOP PR line that the John Doe probe is a "witch hunt" though the fact is the John Doe probe that has determined Scott Walker is at the center of a "criminal scheme" is being run by Wisconsin constitutional law enforcement officials who are publicly proclaimed to be Republican and Democratic, and who are sworn officers of the sovereign state of Wisconsin.

Knockdown

In the ninth graf, readers are treated to the knockdown by "David Deininger, the retired appeals court judge who chaired the board during the launching of the John Doe investigation, defended Kennedy and the GAB staff Friday."

"Deininger was skeptical about the assertions made in the complaint. He said he didn’t recall exactly when the board was made aware of the investigation, 'but something of this magnitude would have been brought to our attention at the earliest opening.'"

'They would know this would have been something the board needed to be up to speed on from the get-go,' Deininger said.

He also vouched for Kennedy and Becker, saying impartial administration of election laws was their 'modus operandi.'"

Deininger's quote demolishes Hall's piece and should have killed it.

Omission

Hall quotes Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos (R-Rochester) and another Republican without mentioning that Vos and the Republicans have already insisted publicly on direct gubernatorial appointments to the GAB, a partisan power grab of which Hall is certainly aware.

Hall opines "The records add ammunition to Republicans in the state Legislature seeking to overhaul or abolish Wisconsin’s elections and ethics watchdog agency," as though the proposed dismantling of the non-partisan agency has not been part of Republican machinations in the manner of Walker's appointments to the Wisconsin Judicial Commission in 2012, picked by a corporate lobbyist (Millhiser, ThinkProgress).

Tell me Hall could not get a jurist or elected officeholder to describe Vos' nonsense as a power grab on the record. Hall omits what is common knowledge of the GOP's aversion to the GAB or any independent agency that would hold GOP officials to account for criminality and corruption.

There's more, but Hall blew this piece, and the Republican Party of Wisconsin can celebrate the news columns of the Wisconsin State Journal once again.

Sep 17, 2014

ACLU Files Emergency Appeal to Vacate Stay of Appellate Panel, Protect the Vote

Update: Emergency petition can be found here.

The ACLU has filed an Emergency Petition for a Rehearing En Banc (before the full Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit) Tuesday in an effort to halt the Wisconsin Voter ID law and save the voting rights of 10,000s of Wisconsin citizens.

This legal case is a partisan issue. The Republican Party of Wisconsin remain hostile to voting rights of all eligible Wisconsin citizens while Democratic Party takes the position of defending the voting rights of all eligible Wisconsin citizens.

Make no mistake, Scott Walker and J.B. Van Hollen are attempting to steal this election by disenfranchising Wisconsin voters.

The Emergency Petition notes last Friday panel's order "involves a question of exceptional importance under Fed. R. App. P. 35(b)(1)(B) because it imposes a radical, last-minute change to procedures for conducting an election that is already underway. The risk of disenfranchisement from imposing such a last-minute disruption far outweighs the non-existent harm to the state of maintaining the status quo and not requiring photo ID for one more election. Supreme Court precedent and other Circuits uniformly caution against such eleventh-hour changes to the election laws, even where those courts have approved such changes for future elections. ..."

... It is not only unreasonable, but also mathematically, logically, and physically impossible that by November 4, hundreds of thousands of voters will learn about the need for ID, especially given the total Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 623  suspension of public information about the law for two and one-half years, collect multiple required documents, get to a DMV office, and obtain the ID suddenly required by staying the District Court‟s injunction last Friday afternoon. Doing so would require Wisconsin to issue some 6,000 photo IDs per day between now and the election. ..."

... The Petition notes that a "fundamental change in election procedures just before an election will sow confusion among voters and elections officials. ..."  

... The panel's decision to allow Act 23 to go into effect at this late date virtually guarantees substantial chaos in election administration and resulting voter confusion and disenfranchisement in the November elections. This will be contrary to the public interest, and will undermine voter confidence."

The EMERGENCY PETITION FOR REHEARING AND SUGGESTION FOR REHEARING EN BANC OF PANEL ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO STAY statement and argument are below [footnotes, citations and other characters such as page numbers are included):

STATEMENT REQUIRED BY FED R. APP. P. 35(b)(1) Pursuant to Fed. R. App. P. 2, 35(b), 40 Plaintiffs-Appellees file this Emergency Petition for Rehearing En Banc, which should be granted for two reasons:
First, the panel decision involves a question of exceptional importance under Fed. R. App. P. 35(b)(1)(B) because it imposes a radical, last-minute change to procedures for conducting an election that is already underway. The risk of disenfranchisement from imposing such a last-minute disruption far outweighs the non-existent harm to the state of maintaining the status quo and not requiring photo ID for one more election. Supreme Court precedent and other Circuits uniformly caution against such eleventh-hour changes to the election laws, even where those courts have approved such changes for future elections. See Purcell v. Gonzalez, 549 U.S. 1 (2006).

Second, the panel‟s extraordinary decision to grant a stay pending appeal – which altered rather than maintained the status quo – ignored the four-factor test for such relief set forth by the United States Supreme Court in Nken v. Holder, 556 U.S. 418, 434 (2009), and the Court‟s admonition against last-minute reversals of lower court election law rulings in Purcell v. Gonzalez, 549 U.S. 1, 4-5 (2006).

Specifically, the panel decision failed to consider that issuance of the stay and the consequent slapdash implementation of a complex law – which was designed to have a rollout period of 8 months before a primary and 16 months before a general election – “will substantially injure” the rights of voters without ID, and that “the Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 622  public interest lies” strongly against fundamentally changing the rules of an election on the eve of the election, particularly where absentee voting is already underway. In addition, the panel decision failed to consider seriously one of the “most critical” factors. Defendants will not be “irreparably injured absent a stay,” Nken, 556 U.S. at 434, if the election proceeds without a photo ID requirement, as has been the case in all but one election in Wisconsin‟s history.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

Wisconsin adopted Act 23 in the spring of 2011 to require voters to present one of a limited number of forms of photo ID to vote in-person or, with very limited exceptions, by absentee ballot. Act 23 was in effect for only one low-turnout primary in February 2012, after which it was enjoined by state and federal courts. In light of the injunctions, Wisconsin suspended the photo ID requirement itself and all implementation of the Act, including training of the 1,852 municipal clerks who run Wisconsin elections and tens of thousands of poll workers, and all public information and educational outreach to voters for two and a half years. In this case, the district court found that approximately 300,000 voters do not have the most common form of ID that would now be needed to vote on November 4 (exactly 7 weeks from today), which is an unexpired driver‟s license or state-issued photo ID. See Frank v. Walker, No. 11–CV–01128, 12–CV–00185, 2014 WL 1775432, at *11 (E.D. Wis. Apr. 29, 2014). It is not only unreasonable, but also mathematically, logically, and physically impossible that by November 4, hundreds of thousands of voters will learn about the need for ID, especially given the total Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 623  suspension of public information about the law for two and one-half years, collect multiple required documents, get to a DMV office, and obtain the ID suddenly required by staying the District Court‟s injunction last Friday afternoon. Doing so would require Wisconsin to issue some 6,000 photo IDs per day between now and the election.  Nevertheless, on September 12, 2014, a panel of this Court granted Defendants‟ motion for a stay of the district court‟s injunction forbidding implementation of the photo ID requirement. By granting a stay on the eve of this year‟s elections, with thousands of absentee ballots already in the mail, the panel decision forces a radical change in election procedures with no time for preparation, training, or outreach. Such a radical change is improper when a state‟s “election machinery is already in progress.” Reynolds v. Sims, 377 U.S. 533, 585 (1964).  Moreover, the panel‟s decision referenced submissions by Defendants tendered several hours after oral argument, see ECF 61, concerning the state‟s new policies (apparently adopted a day earlier) responding to the Wisconsin State Supreme Court‟s decision in Milwaukee Branch of NAACP v. Walker, 2014 WI 98, ¶¶ 62-63 (July 31, 2014) (NAACP). That case, recognizing the “severe burdens” imposed by Act 23, required the Wisconsin Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) to make free IDs available to those who would otherwise have to pay for documents like birth certificates to get ID. 2014 WI 98, ¶ 70. After six weeks, with no official action, counsel for Defendants announced for the first time during oral argument on September 12, 2014, that DMV had issued new emergency rules that purport to Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 624  address the identified deficiencies. Before and during argument, Plaintiffs had no opportunity to view these rules, much less question or dispute them. Defendants filed them after oral argument concluded. ECF 61. Soon thereafter, and without affording Plaintiffs any opportunity to respond, the panel issued the stay, reasoning that NAACP and the state‟s new policies “reduce[] the likelihood of irreparable injury” to plaintiffs and “change the balance of equities.” ECF 64 at 2.  The panel‟s decision to allow immediate implementation of Act 23 this close to an election will sow chaos at the polls and undermine election integrity and public confidence in the November 4 election. The decision raises questions of voting rights and election administration that are of exceptional public importance.  Fed. R. App. P. 35(a)(2). The risk of disenfranchisement and electoral chaos from granting a stay far outweighs the abstract harm to the state in delaying photo ID for one more election. Plaintiffs therefore request that this Court reconsider the panel‟s decision or review the panel‟s decision en banc on an expedited basis and vacate the stay order, which will simply preserve the status quo while the panel reviews the merits of the appeal.1 See Fed. R. App. P. 35(a) (providing for en banc review of an appeal “or other proceeding”); Flower Cab Co. v. Petitte, 685 F.2d 192, 195 (7th Cir. 1982) (Court of Appeals has power to grant rehearing or rehearing en                                                  1 Plaintiffs request that consideration of this petition be expedited pursuant Fed. R. App. P. 2. Time is of the essence to avoid a rush to implement Act 23 without adequate training or preparation, which is already causing confusion among voters, elections officials, clerks and poll workers that will inevitably interfere with election administration and lead to the unnecessary and unlawful disfranchisement of many voters. See 16A Wright, Miller & Cooper, Federal Practice & Procedure: Jurisdiction 3d § 3948, at 25 (1999); 1967 Advisory Committee Note to Fed. R. App. P. 2; Groendyke Transport, Inc. v. Davis, 406 F.2d 1158, 1162 (5th Cir. 1969).  Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 625  banc of a stay granted by a panel of the Court).

ARGUMENT

As the Supreme Court explained in Nken, courts must consider four factors when deciding whether a stay is warranted: (1) whether the stay applicant has made a strong showing that he is likely to succeed on the merits; (2) whether the applicant will be irreparably injured absent a stay; (3) whether issuance of the stay will substantially injure the other parties interested in the proceeding; and (4) where the public interest lies.  556 U.S. at 434 (citations omitted). “The first two factors of the traditional standard are the most critical.”  Id. The “party requesting a stay bears the burden of showing that the circumstances justify” a stay. Id. Here, by failing to balance the dramatic harm to the public and to voters who currently lack ID in changing the rules of an election at the eleventh-hour against the lack of any irreparable harm to the state in waiting to implement photo ID for one election, the panel‟s decision fails to heed the proper standard articulated in Nken, and should be overturned.

I.  FUNDAMENTALLY CHANGING THE RULES JUST BEFORE AN ELECTION WILL SUBSTANTIALLY HARM THIRD PARTIES AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST WITH NO APPRECIABLE BENEFIT TO THE STATE  In issuing the stay, the panel made no finding as to the effect of its decision on other parties and the public interest. This omission is particularly glaring because this factor points decisively against a stay.  A. No court has permitted a voter ID law to go into effect this close to an election based on last-minute changes to the law.  Last-minute orders changing election procedures – particularly from an Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 626  appellate court reversing a district court – are strongly disfavored, because “[c]ourt orders affecting elections, especially conflicting orders, can themselves result in voter confusion and consequent incentive to remain away from the polls. As an election draws closer, that risk will increase.”  Purcell, 549 U.S. at 4-5. No court has permitted a voter ID law to take effect based on purported ameliorative changes adopted this close to an election. For examplehttp://www.jsonline.com/news/appeals-panel- questions-why-voter-id-shouldnt-be-in-place-nov-4-b99350157z1-274904111.html, The record was clear before the stay that this was likely to be the case. See ECF 53 (Plaintiffs-Appellees‟ Opposition to Defendants-Appellants' Expedited Motion to Stay Permanent Injunction Pending Appeal and ECF 56-2 at 3 (Declaration of Kevin J. Kennedy).  4 See Dee J. Hall, Absentee ballots already cast will need photo ID, elections official says, NEWS REPUBLIC (Sept. 16, 2014), http://www.wiscnews.com/baraboonewsrepublic/news/state-and- regional/article_3de3068c-18f3-5887-bb10-3648b28d6eab.html; Patrick Marley, Voters who returned absentee ballots must send ID copies, J. SENTINEL (Sept. 16, 2014), http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/ballot-fight-is-brewing-as-state- scrambled-on-voter-id-b99352576z1-275311521.html.  Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 629  way, printing the ballots. Absentee ballots have indeed already been sent . . . .”); Fishman v. Schaeffer, 429 U.S. 1325, 1330 (1976) (Marshall, Circuit Justice) (denying “extraordinary relief” where absentee ballots were being printed and distributed).5 Even Defendants‟ trial witness municipal clerk Diane Hermann-Brown admitted the stay “complicates the election for clerks because it comes as voters are already requesting and in some cases receiving absentee ballots.”6  C. Voters without ID will be substantially harmed by a stay, given their lack of information and inability to rapidly obtain ID.    On the eve of an election, “the Court of Appeals was required to weigh  . . . considerations specific to election cases,” and to “give deference to the discretion of the District Court.” Purcell, 549 US at 4. Failure to do so constitutes error. Id. Yet the panel failed to consider the “substantial harm” to 300,000 registered voters that the district court found lack ID,7 many of whom do not use ID in their daily lives or who have a form of ID, like Veterans‟ Administration ID, that is not acceptable for voting.8 Frank 2014 WL 1775432, at 2. These voters have no reason to know they 5 See also Nader v. Blackwell, 230 F.3d 833, 834-35 (6th Cir. 2000) (inappropriate to change party-identification procedures after absentee ballots already printed and mailed); Perry v. Judd, 471 Fed. Appx. 219, 2012 WL 120076, at *8 (4th Cir. Jan. 17, 2012) (change in rules after absentee ballots already printed would be improper); cf., Williams, 393 U.S. at 35 (last minute ballot change could interfere with rights of absentee voters). 6 Jason Stein and Patrick Marley, Absentee ballot mailings halted in push to restart voter ID law, J. SENTINEL, http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/clerks- elections-officials-scramble-to-reinstate-voter-id-law-b99351689z1-275146501.html 7 Many voters who have obtained ID since 2011 were not new voters without ID, but voters renewing ID or replacing lost or stolen ID cards. Frank v. Walker, 11-CV- 01128, 2014 WL 1775432 at 38 (E.D. Wis. Apr. 29, 2014). 8 The stay will also impose substantial harm on student voters. Regular student ID Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 6210  would even need ID to vote less than two months from now, because the Government Accountability Board (GAB), which administers elections, suspended all public information and outreach about the law in March 2012. NAACP, 2014 WI 98 at ¶¶ 15-16. Cf. South Carolina, 898 F. Supp. 2d at 49-50 (insufficient time for voters to learn requirements and obtain ID); U.S. Student Ass'n v. Land, 546 F.3d 373, 387-8 (6th Cir. 2008) (voter confusion that would result from stay constitutes harm to others and to public interest). But Act 23 will offer no fail-safe affidavit option for voters without ID, rendering this law materially different from Indiana‟s. Contrast, Crawford v. Marion Cnty. Elections Bd., 553 U.S. 181, 185-6 (2008). Although Act 23 required public information and voter assistance, id. at §§ 95, 144(1), GAB had no intention of even developing a new plan for public information and outreach until 2015, much less a plan that can be implemented to reach voters in less than two months to ensure that these voters understand Act 23, how to get ID, and the new procedures for obtaining it.9  Defendants‟ emergency rules will not even be published until September 17.10  Other than press releases,                                                                                                                                                              cards are not acceptable for voting in Wisconsin and colleges‟ plans to produce alternative voting IDs that expired no more than two years after issuance were reportedly put on hold after the injunctions. Jason Stein and Patrick Marley, Absentee ballot mailings halted in push to restart voter ID law, J. SENTINEL, http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/clerks-elections-officials-scramble-to- reinstate-voter-id-law-b99351689z1-275146501.html  9 See, http://gab.wi.gov/sites/default/files/event/74/09_04_14_gab_complete_open_session_a genda_material_20954.pdf (at 76; p. 79 of PDF) (stating that GAB will be in a better position to develop plan for effective use of state funds to meet voter ID law objectives after Jan. 1, 2015).  10 ECF 61-1, third link at p. 3 (Letter to Legislative Reference Bureau.) Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 6211  there has been no apparent public information or outreach, and the state “has no money available” for further public outreach.11  Furthermore, it does not appear that DMV staff have been fully and uniformly trained to implement the new procedures.12 DMV has only 92 offices statewide, (Frank, 2014 WL 1775432 at 15); and in 48 counties representing over a quarter of the state‟s population, those offices are open only two days a week for a total of ten hours.13 DMV is simply incapable of processing a substantial number of applications from the 300,000 registered voters without ID. Nor are the new rules a panacea. All voters still have to obtain and produce proof of identity and residency and travel to DMV.14 Voters who do not have birth certificates in their possession must complete a petition form with information relevant to the date and circumstances of birth. This initiates a two-step verification procedure. First, the DMV shall provide the birth information to the department of health services and attempt to obtain verification of the                                                  11 See Marley, supra note 4. 12 A “DMV hotline worker told us they're still getting up to speed with the new procedure and that it just came down yesterday, so clearly, the agency is still working through this.”  “New voter ID law rules cause confusion,” CBS58 News (Sept. 13, 2014, updated  Sept. 14, 2014), viewed 9/14/14 at http://www.cbs58.com/news/local-news/New-voter-ID-law.html ) 13 Todd Milewski, Clock is ticking to get a Wisconsin voter ID before November election, faster in some areas, THE CAP TIMES, http://host.madison.com/news/local/writers/todd-milewski/clock-is-ticking-to-get-a- wisconsin-voter-id-before/article_d1346760-3cf1-11e4-9560-df1946b2278e.html  14 See, e.g., Ann-Elise Henzl, Agencies, Advocates Await Word on How to Help Wisconsin Voters Obtain Photo IDs, MILWAUKEE PUBLIC RADIO, http://wuwm.com/post/agencies-advocates-await-word-how-help-wisconsin-voters- obtain-photo-ids. Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 6212  information. ECF 61-2 at 8 (Sec. 11 (creating Wis. Adm. Code Trans. 102.15(5m)(2)1.) DMV warns Wisconsin-born voters that the process may take seven business days to complete. Attachment A. In addition, efforts to implement matching procedures involving different database formats routinely experience severe and unexpected problems and delays.15 If that does not verify required information, then DMV must notify the applicant that the applicant needs to provide other documents, and a DMV administrator or his delegate then has discretion to accept alternatives such as hospital records, baptismal certificates, or other such records. Id. at 8-9 (creating Wis. Adm. Code Trans. 102.15(5m)(2)2.)  ECF 61-2 at 8 (Sec. 11 (creating Wis. Adm. Code Trans. 102.15(5m)(2)1.) Moreover, DMV currently has an agreement to verify birth information only with Wisconsin’s vital records office.16 Even though Election Day is now only seven weeks away, GAB has indicated that the verification process could take eight weeks for voters born in other states.17  Indeed, no formal verification system has been set up for these voters. The state represented at oral argument that this process is ongoing, but the state has reportedly done no more than notify other states of its rules.18 DMV itself is telling voters that “for voters born in another                                                  15 See, e.g, Coverage in jeopardy for 40% of HealthCare.gov enrollees, http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2014/06/40-percent-of-healthcare-gov- accounts-in-jeopardy/index.htm (describing database matching problems in implementation of HealthCare.gov). 16 (WI Dept. of Trans. http://www.dot.state.wi.us/news/releases/031- nr20140910.html) 17 See Hall, supra note 4. 18 Ann-Elise Henzl, Voter ID: No Birth Certificate Needed to Apply for Wisconsin ID Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 6213  state or country, the length of the process will depend upon how long it takes the other government agency to respond to Wisconsin‟s request for information.” Attachment A.  Thus, thousands of Wisconsin voters – especially those born elsewhere – are unlikely to benefit from the new procedures in time to vote. Almost 47% of eligible Milwaukee voters without ID were born outside Wisconsin. (A.187.)  This population is disproportionately comprised of Blacks and Latinos, who are more likely than whites to lack both ID and a document needed to get ID, such as birth certificates, Frank 2014 WL 1775432 at 29-30.19  The fate of voters whose birth records are not verified through this matching process will rest in the hands of front-line DMV employees, who will be charged with deciding when and whether alternative documents are acceptable, a situation that has led to arbitrary and disparate treatment in the past and has not gotten ID to voters. See Frank, 2014 WL 1775432 at 16 n. 18 and n. 20.ECF 61-2 at 8-9 (Wis. Adm. Code Trans. 102.15(5m)(2)2). Cf. Louisiana v. United States, 380 U.S. 145, 153 (1965).  D.  A fundamental change in election procedures just before an election will sow confusion among voters and elections officials.   The panel‟s decision to allow Act 23 to go into effect at this late date virtually
                                                                                                                                                             at DMV Office, http://wuwm.com/post/voter-id-no-birth-certificate-needed-apply- wisconsin-id-dmv-office. 19 See also, Frank 11-CV-01128, 2014 WL 1775432 at 30 n. 37 (“Many Latino voters who were born in Puerto Rico will have trouble obtaining their birth certificates because the Puerto Rican government annulled all birth certificates of individuals born there prior to 2010. . . . 16.7% of eligible Latino[ voters] in Milwaukee County were born in Puerto Rico and 38.4% of those born in Puerto Rico ha[ve] yet to obtain a new birth certificate.”) Case: 14-2058      Document: 65-1            Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 6214  guarantees substantial chaos in election administration and resulting voter confusion and disenfranchisement in the November elections. This will be contrary to the public interest, and will undermine voter confidence. The necessary steps to implement Act 23 – which originally contemplated an eight-month implementation period – cannot be completed in time for this fall‟s election cycle.20 See Fr. Ex. 635 at 74 (deposition testimony of former GAB Elections Division head Robinson) (“This is a new sweeping law with a lot of nuances, and for poll workers who do not do this as a matter of their daily jobs . . . the facts that should be known, the basic facts, in fact, are many times not known.”). The GAB will have to figure out how to retrain the 1,852 municipal clerks who run elections in Wisconsin, roughly one-fifth of all the clerks in charge of elections in the nation,21 as well as ensuring immediate retraining of tens of thousands of poll workers. This process is neither easy nor straightforward, see, e.g., Doc. 53-1 at 15, as Act 23 is extremely complex. Clerks and poll workers must learn exactly what forms of ID are acceptable (e.g., only some specialized college IDs, not regular student IDs) and what IDs are not (e.g., Veterans‟ Administration ID), which IDs are valid despite varying permissible expiration dates, and whether and to what extent the name, 20 Act 23‟s photo ID provisions were scheduled to have a “soft implementation” beginning on July 1, 2011, and to not take mandatory effect until the February 2012 low turnout primary. Id., § 144 (2); http://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/2011/related/acts/23 ; Tr. 908. 21  See, e.g., Jason Stein and Larry Sandler, 1850 municipal clerks another complication, J. SENTINEL, http://www.jsonline.com/news/statepolitics/119373789.html  These clerks also have a 20-25% annual turnover rate, Tr. 889-90, and thus many were never trained on voter ID. Case: 14-2058& Document: 65-1 Filed: 09/16/2014      Pages: 6215  photograph, signature, or address on the ID has to match voter registration data.22

II. ALLOWING THE SAME ELECTION PROCEDURES TO REMAIN IN PLACE FOR ONE MORE ELECTION DOES NOT RESULT IN IRREPARABLE HARM TO THE STATE 

When weighed against such a substantial risk of election official confusion and disenfranchisement, the error of the panel‟s decision is all the more important because of its failure to consider “whether the applicant will be irreparably injured absent a stay.” Nken, 556 U.S. at 434. Other circuits have rejected stay motions when the government has not sustained its burden on this factor. See, e.g., Ohio State Conf. NAACP v. Husted, 2014 WL 4494938, (6th Cir. Sept. 12, 2014) (denying stay where “Defendants did not carry their burden to demonstrate that they will suffer more than a mere „possibility‟ of irreparable harm.”) Id. 

CONCLUSION

It is not too late to avert this impending disaster. GAB Executive Director Kevin Kennedy has stated publicly that his agency would cease efforts to implement this law “if ordered to stop by a court order.”23 For the reasons set forth herein, this Court should so order. Plaintiffs request that this Court reconsider or reconsider en banc its Sept. 12, 2014 ruling and vacate the stay that was issued.

Sep 13, 2008

Subject Matter Experts or Partisan Hack

Update: See Dane County Case Number 2008CV004085 for more information on this DoJ Petition for a Writ of Mandamus.

As reported in the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel,

Republican Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen sued the state this week to require more checks of voter information against driver's license records - a move that critics say could force people off the voter rolls and require them to cast provisional ballots. Provisional ballots are counted only when voters provide proof of residence by the next day.

Van Hollen asked a Dane County judge Friday to expedite proceedings in the case because the election is fast approaching. A hearing is scheduled for Thursday.
The imperative of Wisconsin to establish a centralized, computerized voter registration list "coordinated with other agency databases within the State" like the DOT comes from federal law, the Help America Vote Act (HAVA), which Van Hollen cites in the DOJ Complaint.

But the administrative implementation of HAVA is at best problematic for states with limited resources.

But instead of ceding to the subject matter experts (the Government Accountability Board (GAB)) on implementing HAVA, the partisan Van Hollen wants to call the shots, taking his cues from the GOP voter suppression campaign, in the name of stamping out voter fraud and removing voters from the state voter list, as Van Hollen writes in his complaint, referencing fraud though refusing to mention that it almost never occurs:


The state maintains the obligation of "… preventing election fraud and illegally cast ballots…" and has "...an express obligation to ensure that ineligible voters are removed from Wisconsin’s statewide computerized voter registration list."
As noted widely, Van Hollen seeks a judicial order requiring all election clerks to coordinate voter information with DOT driver's license records for those voters who registered to vote or changed their address from Jan. 1, 2006, to Aug. 5, 2008.

Van Hollen files his complaint fully aware that correlating voter names from the state voter list with driver’s licenses has already been demonstrated to result in 100,000s of mismatches of eligible voters, including GAB members being mismatched, and that what he seeking would cause massive confusion and delay, and force 100,000s of voters to come back the day after Election Day with corroborating information to make their provisional ballots count.

Van Hollen’s remedy, if his wins his suit, would erect barriers on the very Election Day that is expected to break records in the number of Wisconsin citizens casting ballots.

So at next Thursday’s hearing, we may get to see who wins at Dane County Judge Maryann Sumi's courtroom:

- The subject matter experts (the Government Accountability Board (GAB)) protecting the rights of Wisconsin voters, and responsible for the administration and enforcement of campaign finance, elections, ethics and lobbying laws in Wisconsin

- Or the partisan, voter-suppressing GOP lead by our own Attorney General and McCain campaign co-chair, J.B. Van Hollen

Sep 12, 2008

Judge Hearing DOJ Voter Suppression Case Is No GOP Tool

We have a corrupt Attorney General Van Hollen fronting for the national GOP against Wisconsin's Government Accountability Board (GAB) that is sticking up for Wisconsin voters.

Van Hollen's DOJ Complaint was filed with Dane County Judge Maryann Sumi's office.

So who is Maryann Sumi?

Sumi is listed as a supporter of former Wisconsin Supreme Court Judge Louis Butler on his website for his unsuccessful reelection bid.

Butler was defeated by the GOP political machine on April 1 by former Burnett County Circuit Judge Michael Gableman.

Sumi has been on the bench since 1998 and enjoys a reputation as a fine jurist and political liberal, informed observers say.

Old South in Wisconsin

Update II: See The Truth About Vote Fraud.

Update: It was all of one week ago that Van Hollen was making a speech to Wisconsin GOP delegates extolling the virtues of Sarah Palin, saying she will help expand the Republican Party (MJS, Greg J. Borowski, Sept. 4, 2008). Now this McCain Co-Chair says with a straight face that he has no conflict of interest and that he does not act for partisan or political reasons. Borowski's MJS piece notes that, "Van Hollen stressed Palin's pro-life credentials, terming her 'somebody who believes in God, who believes in family, who believes in life.'"
Van Hollen also called the Republican Party a "family".

It's fitting in a sad, ironic sense that the state and its record number of voters that catapulted Barack Obama to the nomination on February 17 now sees the GOP going old south in bringing the machinery of government to halt people from voting in November.

J.B. Van Hollen is attempting to sow delay and erect barriers on election day in the hope that the suppression (a la Ohio in 2004) will sufficiently frustrate the efforts of working people to swing an election to the GOP.

Wisconsin is seen by the GOP as a critical state in its path to 270 electoral votes.

“The rule Attorney General Van Hollen wants the (board) to implement would cause long lines and confusion at the polls on a day when a record number of citizens will be seeking to exercise their right to vote,” writes the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin said in a news release. The League added: “Worst of all, it would mean that many, many Wisconsin citizens would not be able to cast a vote and have it counted.” (MJS, September 12)

It's time for elected officials of all political stripes to speak up and challenge the shameful efforts by the corrupt GOP Wisconsin Attorney General (Wisconsin's co-chair for McCain's presidential campaign), the latest in a long line of GOP voter suppression players.

Van Hollen files his legal complaint with the full knowledge that correlating voter names with driver’s licenses has already been demonstrated to result in 100,000s of mismatches of eligible voters.

The remedy for such voters: Delay, confusion and frustration as voters make their way through bureaucratic barriers Van Hollen and the GOP want to see erected.

“Van Hollen is doing the bidding of the Republican Party to compromise the right to vote for hundreds of thousands of legal Wisconsin voters,” said Scot Ross, One Wisconsin Now Executive Director. “And he’s making taxpayers pick up the tab both for filing the frivolous, partisan suit and defending against it.”

Some links:
- One Wisconsin Now
- WI DOJ site
- August 27 Letter to the Government Accountability Board
- Aug 28 Response From the Government Accountability Board
- Sept 10 Accountability Board Replies to Attorney General’s Lawsuit

Sep 11, 2008

Voter Suppression Fight Is On

On first read of DOJ correspondence and complaint, I do not find any DOJ response to GAB's stated concern about eligible voters getting disenfranchised:

"... preliminary data that showed more than a fifth of voters’ data mismatched due to variations in names, differing data entry standards, or typographical errors. A check conducted of G.A.B. members’ data resulted in four of six Board members’ information mis-matching." [Sept 10 Accountability Board Replies to Attorney General’s Lawsuit]

The DOJ Complaint could have been written by the RNC: "Because of the defendants' inaction, properly qualified voters are at risk of having their vote diminished and diluted by the votes of unqualified, ineligible voters who are not entitled to cast ballots."

Who and what ineligible voters?

Van Hollen writes in the DOJ PR that "I promised that I would work to restore integrity to this office and state government." Funny.

I want to see the GAB response complaint.

This is a national civil rights story.

Where are Feingold, Tammy and Co? And where, excepting liberal blogs, is the outrage?

Some links:
- WI DOJ site
- August 27 Letter to the Government Accountability Board
- Aug 28 Response From the Government Accountability Board
- Sept 10 Accountability Board Replies to Attorney General’s Lawsuit

WI Elect Board Hits DOJ, GOP Voter Suppression

Update: MJS: State lawsuit could affect 1 million voters

The Wisconsin Government Accountability Board (GAB) is hitting back at Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen's and the GOP's voter suppression efforts.

The GAB statement released today concerns Wisconsin's implementation of the Help America Vote Act, (HAVA) a huge project that could disenfranchise some 200,000 Wisconsin voters in the process.

The national and Wisconsin Republican parties have used voter suppression programs as an electoral tool for decades, though the efforts have been rolled out more aggressively the last two presidential elections.

HAVA is proving an irresistible tool for such voter suppression efforts.

The GAB's statement is an aggressive response that is certain to draw howls from the GOP and its tool in this matter, Wisonsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen.

See Accountability Board Replies to Attorney General’s Lawsuit for a full copy of the Government Accountability Board (GAB) statement.

Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen's (R) suit drew the following response from the Government Accountability Board (GAB):

The Board believes it would be counter-productive to rush this effort [cross-checking the voter registration base with the Wisconsin Department of Transportation (DOT)] and to create a significant risk, at best, of unnecessary hardship and confusion at the polls, and at worst, the disenfranchisement of Wisconsin citizens with a clear and legitimate right to vote.

The GAB statement noted the following:

In its deliberations, the Board was concerned about preliminary data that showed more than a fifth of voters’ data mismatched due to variations in names, differing data entry standards, or typographical errors. A check conducted of G.A.B. members’ data resulted in four of six Board members’ information mis-matching.

Full PR is below:

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: FOR MORE INFORMATION, CONTACT:
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 Kyle R. Richmond, 608-267-7887
MADISON, WI – In response to a lawsuit filed Wednesday against the Government Accountability Board (G.A.B.), G.A.B. Director and General Counsel Kevin Kennedy issued the following statement:

“Attorney General Van Hollen has advised the Board that he has filed a lawsuit about a recent decision of the Board concerning the use of a new cross-checking tool developed for its Statewide Voter Registration System (SVRS).

“The SVRS has been in place and used effectively for seven statewide elections since 2006. The Board began using the new cross-checking feature in August 2008. At two public meetings in July and August, G.A.B. members considered a request from the Republican Party of Wisconsin to cross-check the data of all Wisconsin voters entered into the SVRS since January 2006.

“The Republican Party asked that all voters whose records did not match Wisconsin Department of Transportation (DOT) records be required to provide proof of residence at the polling place or to vote on a provisional ballot.
“The Attorney General has asked the court to compel the Board to adopt that position. Neither state nor federal law specifies what must be done with information gathered from the cross-checking function.

“The Board heard testimony from a number of individuals, and carefully considered the issues presented. The Board voted to continue its practice of requiring all new voter registration applications entered into the SVRS to be cross-checked against DOT records, but not to require a retroactive cross-check of individuals who had registered and voted in previous elections.

“In its deliberations, the Board was concerned about preliminary data that showed more than a fifth of voters’ data mismatched due to variations in names, differing data entry standards, or typographical errors. A check conducted of G.A.B. members’ data resulted in four of six Board members’ information mis-matching.

“The Board is committed to properly protecting the electoral process from potential fraud. At the same time, the Board is equally committed to protecting the right of every eligible person to vote in Wisconsin, and that every valid vote must be counted.

“The Board balanced these two fundamental concerns and concluded that it is in the best interest of the citizens of this state to continue its cross-checking efforts until the entire voter database is as accurate as possible.

“The Board believes it would be counter-productive to rush this effort and to create a significant risk, at best, of unnecessary hardship and confusion at the polls, and at worst, the disenfranchisement of Wisconsin citizens with a clear and legitimate right to vote.”
###
The Government Accountability Board (G.A.B.) is responsible for administration and enforcement of campaign finance, elections, ethics and lobbying laws in Wisconsin. The G.A.B. is made up of six non-partisan, former judges and is supported by an agency of non-partisan staff members.