Showing posts with label David Broder. Show all posts
Showing posts with label David Broder. Show all posts

May 21, 2009

David Broder Gets Worse

Even the most dense of Washington political journalists is taking note of the American people's objection to more war from the Obama administration.

The Dean of the American political journalism, David S. Broder, has a piece out, though of course Broder being Broder manages to miss the point.

To Broder, the cheerleader of George W. Bush and Karl Rove, the ideological "left" needs to learn from the new president as he has learned to prolong the wars going so well. Unmentioned are the lies Bush and the neocons told the world with Broder in tow.

Writes Broder the banal:


In every instance, Obama heeded the advice of his uniformed and civilian defense leaders and in each case but Afghanistan, he abandoned a position he had taken as the Democratic presidential candidate.

The predictable result has been the first sustained outcry from the left, angry denunciations from leaders of constituencies that had been early supporters. They feel betrayed as they watch him continuing, with minor modifications, the policies and practices of his Republican predecessor. ...

Ever since Vietnam, the prevailing ideology of grass-roots Democratic activists has been hostile to American military actions and skeptical of the military itself. Iowa, where the Democratic nomination process begins, is famously tilted toward a pacifist view of war. Throughout the primaries, the pressures push forward candidates who do not challenge that mind-set. ...

Obama's liberal critics are right. He is a different man now. He has learned what it means to be commander in chief.

Peace and non-intervention are ideologies for Broder. More war and following the dictates of the neocons (whom Broder tries to align with the military) is what being president really means.

And Democrats need (like George W. Bush?) to become more acquainted with the military to really understand foreign policy and war, no mention of the chicken hawk neocons again.

It's all going so well in Iraq and Afghanistan and Obama just needs to listen and learn to become commander in chief and things will get even better.

And those lying chicken hawks, the $trillions in war costs, the 100,000s of innocents dead, and the constant pissing on the veterans.

That's just the griping left and the Defeatocrats that don't know better.

Listen to the wise men like Broder, Cheney and Bush who saved us from weapons of mass destruction being flown over America in unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) from the "Iraqi dictator (who) must not be permitted to threaten America and the world with horrible poisons and diseases and gases and atomic weapons," as George Bush assured us in the Oct. 7, 2002 speech in Cincinnati.

That was part of the freedom agenda that Broder applauded and cheerleaded without irony or ridicule.

Apr 2, 2009

Obama as TR and Project Manager

David Broder says Obama is flexing his muscles now in the roll out of the recovery.

Let's hope so, but we should understand this the project is a roll out.

Obama can't just do everything at once, if he fails or is delayed (the GOP just might obstruct) then it's over.

This project, by political necessity, needs to rolled out. Economic necessity makes it a crash project.

Jan 12, 2009

Sunlight

The Inauguration of Barack Obama on Jan. 20 marks the end of the single worst presidency in American history, truly our bleakest days.

Never has an administration been so duplicitous and hostile to the cause of liberty as that of George W. Bush.

Looking forward, we see Jan. 20 as a day that has some 20 minutes more daylight than December 20. The long winter is dying down.

Politically, is it possible to have a president whom we believe is dedicated to the oath he to prepared to swear? Yes.

For those who struggle with long winters and this authoritarian, reckless administration, the answer is not to hang on and endure but rather to get busy, work out and see that a lesson of the Bush administration is this: If you let a president, he can ruin a country and the Andrew Sullivans, David Broders and other such cowardly souls will be there to cheer on the carnage.

For the rest of us, we are ready to move forward like our futures depend on it.

Sep 11, 2008

Broder the Banal

Update: Broder was in Madison last night offering his piercing insights.

David Broder is truly the Dean of American corporate journalism and commentary: Inane and living in a comfortable bubble of ideology.

No one is ever quite sure whether the Broders of the world are lying or deluded.

Today, Broder musters out a typical column in the Post: It's too early to call the presidential election for John McCain, no matter the opinion of the "party pros" Broder is in touch with.

Good, Mr. Broder, but what the frack are you talking about?

This is the same guy who can never quite get the nerve to call the Republicans bald-faced liars (we know these guys are liars), so I guess we should not be too surprised at any given Broder column, but he offers this beauty:

What we know is that the American people take the choice of a new president very seriously -- especially when their nation is at war and the economy is behaving in a way that causes real concern.
Actually, what we know is that the American people are remarkably depoliticized and ignorant of basic facts of our society and policies, and take the choice of a new president very casually -- most typically deciding for whom to vote (assuming they bother) based on the most trivial of concerns.

Stating such facts is impolitic to Broder and his ilk, who seem to believe their duty is to rob the American public of its capacity to think, though its capacity to do so is unclear.

Republicans count on voters following the elections very casually and formulating their political opinions flippantly.

Reaching voters is an engineering/marketing/PR project accomplished through appeals made through impressions and images that have nothing to do with such issues as Wars (like we're really mobilized to defeat an enemy), the economy or anything substantive.

One can go on about the many foolish assumptions in Broder's column ... but what is the point. Better to organize and not bother reading this truly trivial writer.

May 3, 2008

Bush/Neocons Against Democracy; McCain Admits War Is for Oil


Update: John McCain: "My friends, I will have an energy policy which will eliminate our dependence on oil from Middle East that will then prevent us from having ever to send our young men and women into conflict again in the Middle East." Said Chris Mattews: "“You know, if somebody else were to say that, they would be accused of being a communist, or radical, or a leftist…for John McCain, a war hero, to say that we’re fighting in the Middle East to protect our oil sources is an astounding development.”

Reading the James Kitfields, neocons, and chickenhawks of the world takes a dose of good humor.

That's because the humanitarian disasters that James Kitfield (along with other neocon cheerleaders, including McCain) excuses and his unseemly enthusiasm for defending the perpetrators tend to grate on the nerves of those for whom tyranny and authoritarianism are repulsive.

Consider James Kitfield in the cover story of the National Journal, Democracy Stalled.

Apparently mystified by the Arab peoples' utter rejection of the American imperial project, Kitfield in his 4,400-word piece references Bush's second Inaugural Address in which Bush, and you can look it up, mentioned "freedom" and "liberty" a whole bunch of times.

Writes Kitfield:
Remarkably, it was just three years ago that President Bush unveiled a new 'freedom' agenda in his second Inaugural Address, rallying the United States and its allies to a generations-spanning effort to transform the Middle East through democracy. In his soaring speech, Bush called the campaign to topple the forces of tyranny and authoritarianism a national security mandate and a moral imperative.
'America's vital interests and our deepest beliefs are now one,' Bush proclaimed. 'We will persistently clarify the choice before every ruler and every nation: the moral choice between oppression, which is always wrong, and freedom, which is eternally right.'

Well, remarkably it was just five years ago that Bush decided to invade Iraq in violation of international law (hey, come along UN if you want to be "relevant"), and proceeded to be forced into accepting direct election of local officials under threat by the Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani.

Now, as civil war continues, Bush is paying Sunnis millions of American tax dollars not to kill our troops, all the while insisting that we must keep the troops there as an occupation force against whoever Bush decides for the moment is the real threat to America.

Though Bush soared in his rhetoric, a quick examination of Kitfield's piece reveals a couple of deflating facts.

He mentioned the word "oil" not once.

Noam Chomsky cuts through this ideological oil constraint nicely in an interview from 2006.

"Doctrinal managers would like us to believe that the US and UK would have 'liberated' Iraq even if its major exports were lettuce and pickles and the major energy resources of the world were in the South Pacific. It takes really impressive discipline 'not to see' the obvious."

Also, Kitfield mentions "Abu Ghraib prison" not once.

These democratic idealists like Kitfield are just too busy analyzing to be bothered by such fare in their pieces.

As Kitfield delves into what What Went Wrong with Bush's idealistic democracy-promoting enterprise, it's worth noting that Kitfield, one has to believe, deliberately ignores the mission, vision, objectives and goals of Bush and his regime.

That would be controlling oil, not exporting democracy.

Carl Estrabrook sums it up nicely, though not on the pages of the National Journal.

Since the Second World War -- from which the United States emerged as the world's only undamaged major country and proceeded to organize the economy of the world -- a cornerstone of American policy has been control of Middle East energy resources, the greatest geopolitical prize in the modern world.

Kitfield ought to consider that no human blood is justified for American control of oil.

Instead he ponders:
Confronted with mounting internal instability, an ascendant Shiite Iran, and empowered Islamist groups throughout the region, authoritarian Sunni Arab governments allied with the United States have cracked down on opposition groups and the press, reversing their own modest democratic reforms. Each day seems to bring news of more opposition figures or government critics arrested and imprisoned, and more restrictions imposed on the press in Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and other countries.

You mean we're invading these countries next? Democracy-exporting sure can be hard work sometimes.

So it is with good humor that one must say to Kitfield and his ilk: Leave democracy and liberty out of it; you're out of your league. And you may wish to ask your editor for a new headline: Imperialism Stalled.

Dec 2, 2007

Is David Broder Capable of Being Substantial? No, That Is Why He Ignores Ron Paul

David Broder has never tried to hide his positive bias toward the Bush, Cheney, and Rove administration.

But Broder's bias extends to the GOP generally, and because it's difficult to manage regular, substantial plaudits for the Party, Broder does what he does best: Banal pandering.

Watching last week's CNN YouTube Debate while attempting to adopt the mindset of a Republican primary voter, the immigrant-bashing, war-mongering, hate-fest nature of the forum was impossible to miss.

John McCain and Mike Huckabee did come out with positions approaching rational and human concern for immigrants and their families, positions similar to the standard Democratic position.

Yet, for David Broder, only GOP candidates draw praise in taking rational positions contra the GOP. [In fairness to Broder, rational GOP positions do not often come.] Writes Broder:

What sets McCain and Huckabee apart is most evident in the way they treat the contentious issue of illegal immigration. ...

But, unlike the others, who seem to take their rhetorical cues from the rabidly anti-immigrant Tancredo, Huckabee and McCain always remember that those who struggle to reach the United States across the deserts or rivers of the Southwest are human beings drawn here by the promise of better lives for their families. ...

If the Republican Party really wanted to hold on to the White House in 2009, it's pretty clear what it would do. It would grit its teeth, swallow its doubts, and nominate a ticket of John McCain for president and Mike Huckabee for vice president -- and president-in-waiting. ...

McCain and Huckabee have been notable for their clarity, character and, yes, simple humanity.

So, does this clarity, character, and humanity apply to the Democratic candidates who have taken essentially the same positions (but less putative) as McCain and Huckabee on immigration? No.

Broder continues:

McCain is ... a principled battler for what he considers essential on Iraq and other national security issues.

McCain's position is that we should sacrifice more American soldiers in Iraq (though even the most dim of observers realize that the war was sold through lies), bankrupt our military's readiness, and begin a massive influx of new troops into the slaughter, a pro-war position that is supposed to appeal to the GOP primary voters.

McCain's pandering to the religious right is well known and merits no further comment, other than to ask Broder whether this is another demonstration of McCain's character.

McCain's principle is that he wants to be president. [Though he chastised Romney on torture at the debate, McCain also has caved in to Bush on torture last year, and besides shouldn't the not-torturing position be axiomatic, and GOP pro-torture positions be the subject of non-stop media and political condemnation?]

Broder says this of Huckabee: "His combination of religious principle, good humor, tolerance and clear passion on education and health care ...," blah blah blah.

Clear passion? Huckabee is against universal health care, and, whatever Broder thinks, Huckabee will not go down in history as the Education Governor.

Huckabee is a religious right zealot who does not believe in evolution, and these beliefs have propelled Huckabee to be the favorite to win the Iowa caucuses.

Broder then writes the following of Ron Paul (and other candidates):

" ... are exercising their lungs but running for exercise, happy to be part of the proceedings but with no hope of being nominated."

Broder, like the national GOP, is afraid of Rep. Ron Paul because of his libertarian, clear anti-war positions, his lack of cant, and criticism of Bush's lies on Iraq that has helped Paul raise millions of dollars in weeks in grassroots' contributions.

And Ron Paul's clarity has earned him the favored candidate status from veterans across the nation.

But for Broder, that will not win Ron Paul (or any Democratic presidential candidate) the praise of having "clarity, character and, yes, simple humanity."
###

Sep 11, 2007

Salon Flops in Interview with Bush Biographer Robert Draper

Presidential historian Robert Draper’s new biographical book on George W. Bush is out, Dead Certain, the Presidency of George W. Bush.

And Salon, typically among the most insightful and candid of journals covering the Bush administration, runs an interview with Draper.

But Salon’s interview with Draper by Rob Patterson is disappointing for employing the same lack of skepticism towards Draper that the establishment writer Draper employs towards the president.

Patterson presupposes that Draper’s extraordinary access to the most-scripted, the most managed, the most-inaccessible-to-critical-and-independent thinkers, and the most vindictive president did not come with a guarantee to Draper’s friend, Bush media strategist and image maker Mark McKinnon, that Draper would not make Bush look like the idiot that he so clearly is.

Not surprisingly, Draper comes to the opposite conclusion.

The interview between Patterson and Draper exemplifies the dance that the Washington media engages in constantly: Let’s all pretend that the president is not an idiot surrounded by liars. David Broder would be proud of these two.

The great journalist H.L. Mencken is reported to have said, “When someone says it's not about the money, it's about the money.”

Today, one can say when someone assures you that George W. Bush is not stupid, Bush is stupid.

Just in case six years of Bush’s inability to answer a question coherently leaves the public doubting Bush’s intelligence, Draper sets us straight.

In the Salon interview, Draper illustrates the president’s brain power, a well-kept secret that Draper tells with great conviction in Dead Certain and in Salon’s interview, in which Draper assures that not only is Bush smart, but he is clear in his vision, and his history-making speeches are a testament to his remarkable lucidity.

Draper: I think that the president's chief attribute is his clarity -- they say people know where he stands. His certitude can come off as steadfastness, as on Sept. 20, 2001, with his great speech.

Wow, I was inspired by that clarity; I wonder if Bush wrote that speech.

Here’s a piercing question from Patterson in the invigorating exchange:
In the book you portray Bush as a voracious reader of history. Does he draw on the lessons of history -- as Santayana put it, that those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it?

Hmmmm, maybe that question would be more properly phrased:

In the book you portray Bush as a voracious reader of history. Are you nuts?

Here’s a wonderfully insightful Draper response from the interview:

But beyond the fact that Bush is charming and there's this incredible loyalty that is cultivated between him and his subordinates, he has a surprising intellect. A guy who reads Cormac McCarthy isn't a dummy. And a guy who can listen to an economist talk about a tax scheme and just eviscerate the guy because he doesn't seem to really understand what he is talking about and there's a loose thread in his argument cannot be intellectually lazy. I think that what's difficult to reconcile is this man's brightness with his capacity for incuriosity.

Draper and Patterson can pretend all they like that Bush is no idiot surrounded by liars. At least among the D.C. establishment media, they’ll have plenty of company.

But readers have come to expect more out of Salon than this fluff.

###