Showing posts with label Andrew Sullivan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Andrew Sullivan. Show all posts

Jun 20, 2020

Unreal Time — Bill Maher, Malcolm Nance and Andrew Sullivan Applaud Rape, Blast Black Lives Matter

Update: If Trump had said, "[Thomas] Jefferson had kids with slaves, so you know he loved black people," on a national cable show, the entire liberal culture would be screaming (rightfully so) bloody murder for days. But Malcolm Nance is an accredited member of the liberal-intelligence-law enforcement Democratic Party elite, so silence is the order.
 ---
Bill Maher, Malcolm Nance and Andrew Sullivan put on a sad show last night at Real Time with Bill Maher.

In a segment featuring Nance from Richmond, Virginia, Sullivan from Provincetown, Massachusetts and Maher from LA, the three neo-libs appeared out-of-touch and cringe-worthy.

The low point of the show came when Maher mentioned that some people today are not thrilled that Washington and Jefferson were slave owners, raising questions about whether slavery should be celebrated.

"Jefferson had kids with slaves, so you know he loved black people," replied Nance.

Maher chuckled, as a slave-owner raping black women is always good for a laugh.
---
Maher and company also assure us police do not routinely harass, defame, imprison and kill people.

The exchanges came as Joe Biden reportedly muses whether to pick an ex-prosecutor, Sen. Kamala Harris, and or ex-cop, Rep. Val Demings, as nominee for vice-president.

It's that "leftist" Black Lives Matter group that has us believing police are so bad, an indignant Andrew Sullivan said, adding he does not support the liberation group.

Sullivan was an avid advocate of the invasion and occupation of Iraq, until he wasn't, and has used Maher's platform in the past to fabricate fictions against Noam Chomsky.

Maher, Nance and Sullivan resembled the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and the Cowardly Lion.

But these three neo-libs were not on a quest to better themselves or help another.

Instead, Maher, Nance and Sullivan smirked and pontificated, still not convinced that Black Lives Matter,
Meanwhile, today in Tulsa, OK, a woman is arrested for breathing. Nothing to see here, say Maher, Nance and Sullivan:

Feb 10, 2010

You're an Anti-Semite If You're Against War

Update: See also Glenn Greenwald's Ugly and Reckless Anti-Simitism Games. "Even by that magazine's lowly standards, The New Republic yesterday published an amazingly ugly, reckless, and at-times-deranged screed from its Literary Editor, Leon Wieseltier, devoting 4,300 words to accusing Andrew Sullivan of being an anti-semite, largely due to his critical (i.e., forbidden) comments about Israeli actions and American neoconservatives. Particularly since the horrific Israeli assault, Sullivan has become more critical of Israeli actions and more dubious of uncritical U.S. support."

One misses the days when those working for peace and standing up for war's victims were merely pinko-commie queers. Now, they're anti-Semites.

Over at the pages of the New Republic is a raging debate over whether neo-con/neo-liberal/neo Andrew Sullivan is per force an anti-Semite as he directs his commentary—as he has the last few years—onto victims of Israeli militarism.

That's a big leap for Sullivan who as recently as 2004 defended the invasion of Iraq ridiculing and slandering the war's detractors such as Noam Chomsky. Sullivan was also a reliable ally of the militarists in Israel.

So what's gotten into Sullivan that he would come to the defense of victims of American-Israeli militarism? If you believe the New Republic, it's anti-Semitism.

It seems unlikely that Sullivan, an intelligent man, could hold to racist views—presumably anti-Semitism requires a belief in the myth of a Jewish raceand the euqally silly notion that races are marked by distinguishing qualities of character inclination and behavior capacities.

No, what Leon Wieseltier says is the give-away is Sullivan "belongs to the party of Mearsheimer and the clique of Walt (whom he cites frequently and deferentially), to the herd of fearless dissidents who proclaim in all seriousness, without in any way being haunted by the history of such an idea, that Jews control Washington."

Actually what Mearsheimer, Walt and now Sullivan apparently believe is that Christain Zionists, militaristic Zionists in America and Israel and AIPAC comprise an enormously effective lobby, and that "... the thrust of US policy in the region derives almost entirely from domestic politics, and especially the activities of the ‘Israel Lobby’. Other special-interest groups have managed to skew foreign policy, but no lobby has managed to divert it as far from what the nationalinterest would suggest, while simultaneously convincing Americans that US interests and those of the other country – in this case, Israel – are essentially identical. London Review of Books (Vol. 28 No. 6 · 23 March 2006))

That's enough to draw the charge of anti-Semitism from American militarists like Wieseltier.
You see, before accusing someone of a historical imprecation like anti-Semite, I would have the decency to have one hell of a lot of evidence. But evidence and decency, the tools of rational analysis, escape Wieseltier when defending the indefensible; that is atrocities, death and destruction that are the favored results of all militarists of any state, creed, and religious persuasion.

War sucks, Wieseltier. That's a truism you find dark and disturbing.

Here, by the way, is an excerpt from the understated text from Mearsheimer and Walt's article in the London Review of Books (Vol. 28 No. 6 · 23 March 2006).
---
The Israel Lobby
John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt

For the past several decades, and especially since the Six-Day War in 1967, the centrepiece of US Middle Eastern policy has been its relationship with Israel. The combination of unwavering support for Israel and the related effort to spread ‘democracy’ throughout the region has inflamed Arab and Islamic opinion and jeopardised not only US security but that of much of the rest of the world. This situation has no equal in American political history. Why has the US been willing to set aside its own security and that of many of its allies in order to advance the interests of another state? One might assume that the bond between the two countries was based on shared strategic interests or compelling moral imperatives, but neither explanation can account for the remarkable level of material and diplomatic support that the US provides.

Instead, the thrust of US policy in the region derives almost entirely from domestic politics, and especially the activities of the ‘Israel Lobby’. Other special-interest groups have managed to skew foreign policy, but no lobby has managed to divert it as far from what the nationalinterest would suggest, while simultaneously convincing Americans that US interests and those of the other country – in this case, Israel – are essentially identical.

Since the October War in 1973, Washington has provided Israel with a level of support dwarfing that given to any other state. It has been the largest annual recipient of direct economic and military assistance since 1976, and is the largest recipient in total since World War Two, to the tune of well over $140 billion (in 2004 dollars). Israel receives about $3 billion in direct assistance each year, roughly one-fifth of the foreign aid budget, and worth about $500 a year for every Israeli. This largesseis especially striking since Israel is now a wealthy industrial state with a per capitaincome roughly equal to that of South Korea or Spain.

Other recipients get their money in quarterly installments, but Israel receives its entire appropriation at the beginning of each fiscal year and can thus earn interest on it. Most recipients of aid given for military purposes are required to spend all of it in the US, but Israel is allowed to use roughly 25 per cent of its allocation to subsidise its own defence industry. It is the only recipient that does not have to account for how the aid is spent, which makes it virtually impossible to prevent the money from being used for purposes the US opposes, such as building settlements on the West Bank. Moreover, the US has provided Israel with nearly $3 billion to develop weapons systems, and given it access to such top-drawer weaponry as Blackhawk helicopters and F-16 jets. Finally, the US gives Israel access to intelligence it denies to its Nato allies and has turned a blind eye to Israel’s acquisition of nuclear weapons.

Washington also provides Israel with consistent diplomatic support. Since 1982, the US has vetoed 32 Security Council resolutions critical of Israel, more than the total number of vetoes cast by all the other Security Council members. It blocks the efforts of Arab states to put Israel’s nuclear arsenal on the IAEA’s agenda. The US comes to the rescue in wartime and takes Israel’s side when negotiating peace. The Nixon administration protected it from the threat of Soviet intervention and resupplied it during the October War. Washington was deeply involved in the negotiations that ended that war, as well as in the lengthy ‘step-by-step’ process that followed, just as it played a key role in the negotiations that preceded and followed the 1993 Oslo Accords. In each case there was occasional friction between US and Israeli officials, but the US consistently supported the Israeli position. One American participant at Camp David in 2000 later said: ‘Far too often, we functioned . . . as Israel’s lawyer.’ Finally, the Bush administration’s ambition to transform the Middle East is at least partly aimed at improving Israel’s strategic situation. ...

Feb 11, 2009

Israel's Horror Show

From former neocon Andrew Sullivan, no less.

[Photo: Olivier Laban-Mattei/AFP/Getty Images.]

A Palestinian schoolgirl inspects her classroom which was burnt during Israel's offensive, at UNRWA's (UN Relief and Works Agency) primary school in Beit Lahia in the northern Gaza Strip on January 24, 2009. Some 200,000 Gaza children returned to school for the first time since Israel's offensive, many having lost family members, their home and their sense of security. The main UNRWA centre and several schools were destroyed by Israeli bombing during the 22-day war. [By Olivier Laban-Mattei/AFP/Getty Images.]

Jan 12, 2009

Sunlight

The Inauguration of Barack Obama on Jan. 20 marks the end of the single worst presidency in American history, truly our bleakest days.

Never has an administration been so duplicitous and hostile to the cause of liberty as that of George W. Bush.

Looking forward, we see Jan. 20 as a day that has some 20 minutes more daylight than December 20. The long winter is dying down.

Politically, is it possible to have a president whom we believe is dedicated to the oath he to prepared to swear? Yes.

For those who struggle with long winters and this authoritarian, reckless administration, the answer is not to hang on and endure but rather to get busy, work out and see that a lesson of the Bush administration is this: If you let a president, he can ruin a country and the Andrew Sullivans, David Broders and other such cowardly souls will be there to cheer on the carnage.

For the rest of us, we are ready to move forward like our futures depend on it.

Mar 26, 2008

Is She Gone Yet?

Andrew Sullivan on Hillary:

Bill Safire was right: she is and has for a long time been a congenital liar. I don't mean by that that she deliberately and pre-meditatedly decides to deceive people. I mean she has long since forgotten the difference between truth and untruth (enabling addicts can do that to people). I mean that by seeking power and self-advancement for so many years, at the expense of any other human values, she has lost all sense of what the difference between truth and falsehood is, who she is, what really matters or any fundamental sense of perspective.

Once, I believe, she was motivated by good intentions and even now, I don't think she believes she is advancing anything but the common good. But she can never believe that her interests and the common good could ever be in conflict, which is to say, she has lost a moral compass beyond narcissism. That is sad in a human being and we are all prey to it. But in a potential president, it is very dangerous. And she has so long excused all her moral transgressions by the fact that her foes must always be worse (yes, for Wolfson, who has long internalized the socipathy of the Clintons, even Obama is Ken Starr to her), she has long lost the ability to ask herself, deep down, who she really is any more. She is a lost and dangerous soul, as her husband still is. She is, in my view, unfit to be president. Truly, deeply unfit. And at some point, someone in the Democratic party has to take her aside and tell her the damage she is doing to herself, her party and her country is enough.

Dec 18, 2007

Andrew Sullivan: The Cost Of Bush Is $32 Trillion and Rising

Via Sullivan's The Daily Dish:

The opinion of another shrill hysteric? Just David M. Walker, the Comptroller General of the United States and head of the GAO:

In a speech today at the National Press Club, he said, "If the federal government was a private corporation and the same report came out this morning, our stock would be dropping and there would be talk about whether the company's management and directors needed a major shake-up." Walker urged greater transparency and accountability over the federal government's operations, financial condition, and fiscal outlook...

"The federal government's fiscal exposures totaled approximately $53 trillion as of September 30, 2007, up more than $2 trillion from September 30, 2006, and an increase of more than $32 trillion from about $20 trillion as of September 30, 2000," Walker said. "This translates into a current burden of about $175,000 per American or approximately $455,000 per American household."

Full (PDF) report here.
###

Oct 2, 2007

Washington Post Smears and Censors Noam Chomsky


Several years ago I interviewed Noam Chomsky on his book Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media prior to his speaking engagement in Madison, Wisconsin.

It was the easiest interview that I have done. I asked two questions, one of which was “for example,” and received extensive and instructive responses.

“Thanks Noam,” I said at the end. All I really needed were a few quotes for a daily newspaper piece, but it was an engaging interview.

As I read Chomsky’s writings, I came to realize later that Chomsky is not popular with a certain class of American intellectuals, and Chomsky’s intellectual foes ranging from Jacob Weisberg, Andrew Sullivan, David Brooks and Jeffrey C. Isaac to far-right writers such as David Horowitz and Peter Collier share a perverse refusal to engage Chomsky in debate.

It’s all about vilification and—though these writers be intellectuals—juvenile name calling.

Typical of this brand of unengaged scorn is the review by Jonathan Rauch (September 2, 2007) of Chomsky’s new Interventions (City Lights) in the Washington Post.

It’s true that a book review cannot dispute a book point-by-point; that’s certainly not the objective of a book review. But one does expect at the very least an intelligent subjectivity.

Jonathan Rauch fails the readers miserably in this regard, and his editors at The Post are even worse.

Echoing David Brooks’ (NYT, January 6, 2004, cited in CounterPunch) “Planet Chomsky” derision, Rauch begins his review by noting that Chomsky is not well known in the “Capital Beltway.”

The reason behind Chomsky’s absence from this intellectual, modern-day Athens owes much to Interventions’ (and Chomsky's) “flights to a separate reality,” “tendentious whimsy,” and the “instant forgettability” of this “tired book,” revealing Chomsky’s inadequacy as the “thinker” necessary to offer the world “ …a pointed, perceptive leftist critique of Bush's foreign policy and America's blind spots.”

And I had no idea that the D.C. Beltway was so high-brow and open to criticism of the establishment foreign policy from a leftist perspective.

But Rauch does note that Chomsky goes so far as to contend that:

America, for Chomsky, has long been a major perpetrator of state terror; but now, with the advent of the Bush administration, ‘The most powerful state in history has proclaimed that it intends to control the world by force.’

Now, where would Chomsky possibly get that idea? Need we even cite?
Let’s just borrow from Brother Martin:

I knew that I could never again raise my voice against the violence of the oppressed in the ghettos without having first spoken clearly to the greatest purveyor of violence in the world today - my own government.
- 4th April, 1967

It’s 40 years later, but one does not require the intellectual acumen of a Capital Beltway political journalist to realize the significance of the National Security Strategy for the United States of America (September 2002).

Rauch does point out, in a rare grappling with Chomsky’s arguments, that “(i)f Bush is pursuing imperialism in Baghdad, it is of a very curious sort,” because our enterprise is not going so well.

You see, the Shiite population in the south is friendly to the Shiite population in Iran (as Chomsky and everyone outside of Washington predicted would happen).

In Rauch’s logic, if imperialism is executed badly, then it must not be occurring at all, no matter those cynics who believe that if Iraq’s main exports were apples we would still be pouring $100s of billions into our efforts to export democracy, and not establishing a client oil state as cynics such as Chomsky believe.

In a rejoinder to Chomsky, Rauch uses the term “sovereign” to describe Iraq today. Call me beholden to a “separate reality,” but if over 350,000 U.S. troops and mercenaries occupy a country against the wishes of its people, then I assert that the country is not sovereign.

However, Rauch explains that: “In truth, foreign policy in the Bush years has blended aggression, humanitarianism, idealism and realism into a strange new brew.”

I see now.

One could go on; but Chomsky offered the Post’s editors a 779-word, point-by-point letter in response to Rauch’s review.

One would think that out of a sense of fairness and concern for offering readers needed information, the Post editors would be happy to run Chomsky’s letter.

Wrong.

But Chomsky knows the score. Below is Chomsky’s preface and unpublished letter now posted on his website. It makes for a nice laugh at Rauch’s expense, really, and calls into question the motivations for the style and substance of the review and the editors’ refusal to allow Chomsky’s response into print.


Posted Wednesday, September 26, 2007

The letter to the Washington Post that follows was written as an
experiment, to see just how low the editors would sink in their efforts to block a book containing evidence and analysis that they do not want to reach the public. The letter is a response to a crude and vulgar diatribe, in the form of a review of my collection Interventions. In response, I wrote a point-by-point refutation of each charge, a straightforward matter, as the editors doubtless understand. The letter was sent to the Post immediately, altogether four times, with a request for acknowledgment of receipt. Unpublished, no acknowledgment of receipt. Two weeks after the review appeared, Sept. 16, the Post did publish two letters responding to it. The letters were critical of the review, but acceptable by the standards of the editors, because they left the lies and slanders standing -- the authors could have had no way to refute them without a research project.

I think it is fair to take the editors' silence to demonstrate that they know precisely what they are doing, and are too cowardly even to acknowledge receipt.

- Noam Chomsky


Editor
Washington Post


Jonathan Rauch's review of my Interventions (WP, Sept. 2) brings to mind Orwell's famous observations on the "indifference to reality" of the nationalist, who "not only does not disapprove of atrocities committed by his own side, but ... has a remarkable capacity for not even hearing about them."


Rauch runs through a series of what he regards as "flights into a separate reality" and "tendentious whimsy." When exposed, a straightforward matter, his charges may appear to be conscious deceit, but are more charitably understood as a textbook illustration of Orwell's observations.

Rauch is appalled that I should charge Washington with bombing Serbia in 1999 "not to prevent ethnic cleansing but to impose Washington's neoliberal economic agenda." I neither made nor endorsed the statement. Rather, I quoted it accurately, not in his words. The source is a high official of the Clinton administration directly involved in the Kosovo events, describing how events were perceived at the highest level. See p. 179.

Another bit of "tendentious whimsy" is the statement that "North Korea’s counterfeiting racket may actually be a CIA operation." I neither made nor endorsed the statement, but cited it, accurately, from the respected Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung.

Rauch finds equally appalling the fact that "In Chomsky’s universe, the 2001 U.S. attack on Afghanistan was undertaken with the expectation that it might drive several million people over the edge of starvation." The statement is precisely accurate. That is why aid agencies bitterly condemned the bombing, joined by leading Afghan opponents of the Taliban, including US favorites. It is also why many months after the bombing ended, Harvard's leading specialist on Afghanistan, Samina Ahmed, wrote in the Harvard journal International Security that "millions of Afghans are at grave risk of starvation." That and more is in the book under review, but in these op-eds I did not provide full details that would be familiar to readers of the mainstream press, for example, the increase in estimate of those at the edge of starvation by 50%, to 7.5 million, when the
bombing was announced and initiated. If Rauch is indeed unfamiliar with the mainstream press, he can find precise references in books of mine cited here.

Particularly amazing in Rauch's universe is the idea, in his words, that "President Bush“ the first and only U.S. president to declare formal American support for a Palestinian state“ is the obstacle to a two-state solution that Hezbollah, Hamas and Iran are all prepared to accept (I am not making that up)." The tiny particle of truth here is that Bush announced his "vision" of a Palestinian state“ somewhere, some day, a pale reflection of the long-standing international consensus on a two-state settlement. Bush did indeed innovate: he is the first president to officially endorse Israeli annexation of the major illegal settlements in the West Bank, a long step backwards from Clinton's "parameters," and a death blow to any hope for a viable Palestinian state, as minimal familiarity with the region demonstrates.

In contrast, Iran's "supreme leader" Ayatollah Khamenei formally announced that Iran "shares a common view with Arab countries on ... the issue of Palestine," meaning that Iran accepts the Arab League position: full normalization of relations in terms of the international consensus. "Khamenei has said Iran would agree to whatever the Palestinians decide," the prominent Iran scholar Ervand Abrahamian observes. If Rauch reads the journal in which he writes, he knows that Hamas Prime Minister Ismail Haniye called for "statehood for the West Bank and Gaza..." (Washington Post, July 11, 2006) There are innumerable other examples, perhaps most important among them the statement of the most militant Hamas leader Khalid Mish'al, in exile in Damascus, calling for "the establishment of a truly sovereign and independent Palestinian state on the territories occupied by Israel in June 1967" (Guardian, Feb. 23, 2007). Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah has repeatedly stated that as a Lebanese organization, Hezbollah will not disrupt anything agreed to by the Palestinians.

Much as it may distress the nationalist, on this matter the positions of Iran, Hamas, and Hezbollah are more moderate“ that is, closer to the long-standing international consensus“ than those of the US and Israel.

In Rauch's universe, Washington "tolerates a sovereign, more or less democratic Iraq whose Shiite government is friendly toward Iran." No comment should be necessary for readers of the daily press.

That exhausts Rauch's charges. Orwell triumphs again.

It is perhaps not surprising that Rauch's furious exertions did not unearth even a misplaced comma. As he knows, the op-eds passed through New York Times fact checking. There might be a lesson there for the journal in which he is a senior writer.

Noam Chomsky
### - Crossposted at UppityWisconsin -