Showing posts with label gays. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gays. Show all posts

Mar 7, 2010

The Last Acceptable Bigotries in America

Befitting our political culture, appeals to the contemporary American bigot are accomplished with sophisticated brands, images, impressions, and coded vocabulary, and not overt prejudices and stereotypes.

But there are two exceptions to this operative prohibition against overt bigotry: Arabs and gays. Two bigoted parties, long-time Editor-in-Chief and owner of The New Republic, Martin Peretz, and the Republican Party, reveal this dynamic.

As for gays [a broad term] the Republican Party and the religious right appear to owe their very reason for existence to the compulsion to marginalize and deny gays due process and equal protection under the law so often are gays the political scapegoat of GOP-religious right operatives. So, we're not surprised to find U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia (R) dissenting in a landmark civil rights case, LAWRENCE V. TEXAS (02-102), writing:

Many Americans do not want persons who openly engage in homosexual conduct as partners in their business, as scoutmasters for their children, as teachers in their children’s schools, or as boarders in their home. They view this as protecting themselves and their families from a lifestyle that they believe to be immoral and destructive.
This is retrograde and repulsive thinking to most Americans, but not most Republicans. Almost daily, we can find anti-gay appeal from Republicans.

Arabs and The New Republic's Martin Peretz

Arabs also enjoy a distinct status as the object of acceptable bigotry in this current milieu (environment) extending across partisan lines. An often bipartisan consensus keeps Ahmad in his place in America. Glenn Greenwald's The Right Kind of Bigotry is nothing short of spectacular in revealing this bigotry widely unchallenged. If you read nothing else, read this 300-word piece below, singling out The New Republic's Martin Peretz as a self-admitted bigot who is also a disingenuous slander artist.

From the long-time Editor-in-Chief and owner of The New Republic, [Martin Peretz] this morning [March 6]:

There were moments--long moments--during the Iraq war when I had my doubts. Even deep doubts. Frankly, I couldn’t quite imagine any venture requiring trust with Arabs turning out especially well. This is, you will say, my prejudice. But some prejudices are built on real facts, and history generally proves me right. Go ahead, prove me wrong.
The point here is so obvious that it makes itself. In the bolded sentence, replace the word ‘Arabs’ with ‘Jews’ and ask yourself: how much time would lapse before the author of such a sentence would be vehemently scorned and shunned by all decent people, formally condemned by a litany of organizations, and have his livelihood placed in jeopardy? Or replace the word ‘Arabs’ in that sentence with ’Jews’ or ‘blacks’ or ’Latinos’ or even ‘whites’ or virtually any other identifiable demographic group and ask yourself this: how many people would treat a magazine edited and owned by such a person as a remotely respectable or mainstream publication (notwithstanding the several decent journalists employed there)? Yet Marty Peretz spits out the most bigoted sentiments of this type -- and he's been doing this for years, as is well known -- and very little happens, because, for multiple reasons, this specific type of hate-mongering remains basically permitted in American political discourse. The double standard at play here is as extreme and self-evident as it is pernicious, but it doesn't matter. And we'll all wait with bated breath for the next installment of The New Republic's righteous, accusatory attacks on the entirely fictitious manifestations of the one strain of bigotry that bothers them, because they're such credible arbiters and opponents of prejudice.

Sep 17, 2009

Homophobia Sweeps the Muslim World

From Spiegel Online, a must-read report.

The Gay Sons of Allah
Wave of Homophobia Sweeps the Muslim World
By Juliane von Mittelstaedt and Daniel Steinvorth
In most Islamic countries, gay men and women are ostracized, persecuted and in some cases even murdered. Repressive regimes are often fanning the flames of hatred in a bid to outdo Islamists when it comes to spreading 'moral panic.'

Sep 1, 2009

Marriage Equity Final Brief Filed

William C. McConkey filed his final brief with the Wisconsin Supreme Court last Friday in his bid to overturn Wisconsin's gay marriage ban.

McConkey's argues in William C. McConkey v. J. B. Van Hollen that the anti-gay marriage referendum resulting in the Wisconsin constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage should be overturned because of ambiguous language in the formulation of the referendum.

The 2005 referendum question submitted to the voters on the marriage amendment is composed of two questions posed in the single referendum.

McConkey argues that this violates the "single subject" rule in Article XII, section 1 of the Wisconsin Constitution mandating that people may vote for or against more than one proposed amendment separately.

In the reply brief filed Friday, McConkey writes:

Wisconsin voters had a right to expect that a crucial issue like the potential rights and obligations of unmarried individuals who are in a relationship that is not marriage would be discussed and considered fully. Instead, it was coupled with a definition of marriage that was emotionally compelling and presented to the voters in a logrolled resolution that stymied debate and restricted the voters’ right to directly discuss and then address in the voting booth all of the issues before them.

The language of the 2005 referendum reads:

Shall section 13 of article XIII of the constitution be created to provide that only a marriage between one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in this state and that a legal status identical or substantially similar to that of marriage for unmarried individuals shall not be valid or recognized in this state? [Emphasis added]
The Wisconsin Department of Justice is defending the anti-gay marriage amendment.

Oral arguments are scheduled for November 3.

Friend of the Court briefs, amicus curiae, will likely also be filed with the Court.

See also:
- DOJ Files Anti-Gay Marriage Brief
- Wisconsin Gay Marriage Ban May Go Down
- Objection, Compound Referendum
- Brief Looks to Doom Wisconsin Gay Marriage Ban

Aug 14, 2009

DOJ Files Anti-Gay Marriage Brief

The Wisconsin Dept of Justice (DOJ) filed its response brief yesterday to a constitutional challenge to Wisconsin’s same-sex marriage ban approved in a 2006 statewide referendum composed of two questions being considered by the Wisconsin Supreme Court in a legal challenge posed by civil rights advocates.

The case, William C. McConkey v. J. B. Van Hollen, challenges the anti-gay marriage referendum on several constitutional grounds, arguing that the state’s resulting constitutional amendment should be overturned.

Constitutional Amendment Referendum

The language of the 2006 referendum reads:

Shall section 13 of article XIII of the constitution be created to provide that only a marriage between one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in this state and that a legal status identical or substantially similar to that of marriage for unmarried individuals shall not be valid or recognized in this state? [Emphasis added]
Single Purpose

One of the issues addressed in the case is the constitutionality of the referendum formulation that poses more than one proposition in a single ballot question that confuses Wisconsin voters.

The related question of how to determine whether such compound-question referenda serve the same general purpose and comprise the same subject matter in accordance with some case law, will also be considered by the Court.

The DOJ argues that the "general purpose of the amendment was to preserve and protect the unique and historical status of traditional marriage as a union between one man and one woman,” echoing the ruling of Dane County Circuit Judge Richard Niess, who upheld the amendment last year, saying in part that the two propositions in the referendum are “two sides of the same coin.”

So how does the Court go about determining if two propositions serve the same general purpose?

McConkey argues and the Court of Appeals April 2009 decision agrees vis a vis Judge Niess, that the “proper legal standard and methodology” for determining a general purpose is unclear from existing case law.

The DOJ brief argues that existing case law accords deference to the legislature’s formulation of referendum questions on proposed constitutional amendments.

Both the DOJ and McConkey briefs suggest judicial standards of ascertaining legislative intent of referendum questions.

Single Subject

The compound formulation of a question promotes ambiguity rendering the electorate’s ballot preference unknown because voters are only able to get to cast one yes or no to the two different questions in clear violation of the " ? Article XII, section 1 of the Wisconsin Constitution.

The DOJ does not see it that way.

Reads the DOJ brief:
The two parts of the ballot question presented to voters in November 2006 related to and furthered the general purpose of the amendment: to preserve and protect the unique and historical status of traditional marriage as a union of one man and one woman. McConkey’s strained effort to conceptually dissociate the two propositions should be rejected.
One wonders how the same general purpose of two parts of the ballot question can be served [voted upon] and ascertained, when a voter might easily be in favor of the first question but not the second question of the referendum.

The strained effort in this matter is imputing a unitary coherence onto the religious right's compound formulation. Whatever the GOP and the religious right were thinking, they did not communicate their propositions clearly to Wisconsin voters.

See also:

- Objection, Compound Referendum
- Brief Looks to Doom Wisconsin Gay Marriage Ban

Jul 9, 2009

Brief Looks to Doom Wisconsin Gay Marriage Ban

Update: McConkey brief is now available online.

Wisconsin's gay marriage ban resolutions were shepherded through the 2003-05 legislative sessions with exclusive Republican support.

But the gay marriage referendum was written so broadly and ambiguously that the resulting constitutional amendment will likely be struck down in the William C. McConkey v. J. B. Van Hollen (Appeal Number 2008AP001868) Wisconsin Supreme court case.

Reading the McConkey brief filed yesterday is like a breath of fresh air; nothing quite like rigorous logic defeating cynical bigotry.

One big problem with the 2006 referendum is that its formulation is a compound question that asks for one response to two different propositions in the same referendum question.

This compound formulation promotes ambiguity rendering the electorate’s ballot preference unknown because voters were only able to get to cast one yes or no to the two different questions in clear violation of the "single-subject" rule set forth in Article XII, section 1 of the Wisconsin Constitution.

Divining a Purpose

Dane County Circuit Judge Richard Niess, who upheld the amendment last year, saying the two clauses in the referendum question were ‘two sides of the same coin’ and properly decided with one vote will likely regret his ill-informed decision that invented a legislative purpose for the two propositons.

Judge Niess said that the legislative purpose of the amendment is the “preservation and protection of the unique and historical status of traditional marriage,” a foolish (and astoundingly ignorant) statement in the face of the dynamic, evolving history of marriage and a purpose he imputes to the legislature with no evidence.

Reads the McConkey brief on this point:


Were the Court to base its determination of a proposed amendment’s purpose on something other than the one found in the Enrolled Joint Resolutions, for instance, by determining purpose from statements made by those participating in the public debate surrounding the amendment, it would be deviating from the determination of purpose already made by the Legislature and legislating from the bench. That is what the circuit court did, when it found that the purpose of the amendment was 'the preservation and protection of the unique and historical status of traditional marriage.' (R. 1, A-App. 7), 2003 J.R. 29 and 2005 J.R. 30 say nothing about preservation, protection, uniqueness, traditional marriage or historical status. [Emphasis added]
Judge Niess can't just make stuff up; he's a judge.

Single Subject

Reads the McConkey brief filed yesterday on the compound question, single subject issue:


The circuit court concluded that the two propositions were ‘two sides of the same coin.’ That is incorrect. Had the second portion of the ballot question merely proposed that ‘marriage between any other individuals shall not be allowed, recognized or valid in this state,’ the circuit court’s observation would be true. But the second proposition was not so limited. It was not the obverse [logical counterpart] of the first.

Rather, the first proposition stated whose marriages would be recognized as valid by the state, and the second proposition limited the legislature’s power to provide to unmarried people a status that is ‘identical or substantially similar’ to marriage. That is a far different purpose than the first.

The Legislature erred by trying to accomplish two separate and distinct things through one ballot question. By having those two distinct purposes, the ballot question violated the single general purpose prong of the single amendment requirement set out in Article XII, Section 1 of the Wisconsin Constitution. Having done so, Article XIII, Section 13 is unconstitutional.

The Attorney General’s reply brief is due on August 13th.

Jul 6, 2009

Summer Breeze or Hurricane Awaits Obama

Update: See TNR's Inexcusable, When will Obama get real on gay civil rights?

Summer is typically a comparatively down time for politics.

Not this summer and not for President Obama.

E.J. Dionne posits that this summer—the 6th through 9th month of Obama's presidency—is a critical period.

But Dionne, generally a fine analyst, gets it wrong by suggesting that Obama's problem is maintaining "support from both the left and the center as he faces potentially divisive choices in the context of a stricken economy."

Dionne says of the left: "For progressives, the president's long-term political well-being depends upon delivering tangible benefits to middle-class voters in areas such as health care, education and financial security, even at the risk of temporarily higher budget deficits."

What does Dionne mean? That whom he regards as centrist voters don't care about health care, education and financial security, and that the solutions progressive see are not popular?

That's crazy. The American public is with Obama on progressive solutions to these issues, and not just the "left."

But absent decisive stimulative action, Obama does face more than a few possible paths to a worse recession.

And those values voters so concerned about transparency, civil liberties, human rights and the Constitution are ignored and repudiated at Obama's political peril.

Not because the American public cares about a transparent, open and democratic government. Let's face it; most Americans don't care about the tenets of democratic government and certainly not about equal protection and civil rights. But Obama's base does care. Does Obama?

Writes Jeff Ronci in the New York Times letter to the editor:


Since his election, President Obama has had unprecedented opportunities to lead and educate on civil rights for gay Americans. His response has been alternately silent, glib, clumsy, indifferent, condescending and cavalier. In his administration’s brief supporting the Defense of Marriage Act, the tone was antagonistic.
One thing for certain is that Obama vis a vis George W. Bush won't be taking long vacations in August and blowing off aides who tell him that terrorists are threatening the United States with attack.

But it's the mounting uncertainties about the direction that Obama wishes to take this country that will make or break this administration this Summer.

See the Democratic Strategist and Ruy Teixeira for more information on public attitudes.

Jun 29, 2009

Ignorance Lives

Bigotry has no supporting arguments.

Bigotry is the lack of argument and rational thinking. It's ignorance directed by hate.

The sense of entitlement that a bigot possesses to impose his hate onto society is an infantile characteristic, a projection of hate often accompanied by seeking a society-wide entitlement for their self loathing.

Civil rights workers are typically concerned about the rights of blacks and gays, women and Arabs, Jews and defendants.

Bigots are more unpredictable, though often they are big supporters of guns and violence.

Frank Rich discusses the gay civil rights movement 40 years after Stonewall.

May 19, 2009

Objection, Compound Referendum

When Wisconsin citizens vote on constitutional amendments, the language should be clear so that a yes or no vote records the voter’s preference on what the referendum proposes.

A clarity issue, a clarity problem, is taken up by the Wisconsin Supreme Court in the Gay Marriage Ban case likely to be decided this year. [See William C. McConkey v. J. B. Van Hollen (Appeal Number 2008AP001868.]

This lack of clarity issue will be adjudicated by considering the "single-subject test" and essentially divining the general purpose behind the gay marriage and unmarried individuals propositions comprising the referendum. [The other issue is whether the Wisconsin voter McConkey has proper standing as a voter to object to the formulation of the referendum.]

The appeals court held that the few cases on point apparently offer conflicting approaches to applying the single-subject test, and that it is not clear what is the “proper method for determining the purpose of a proposed amendment” which would offer some guidance on this issue.

Constitutional amendment language

The language of the 2006 referendum reads:

Shall section 13 of article XIII of the constitution be created to provide that only a marriage between one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in this state and that a legal status identical or substantially similar to that of marriage for unmarried individuals shall not be valid or recognized in this state? [Emphasis added]
Reading the question‘s 59 words, it’s easy to spot a problem in the formulation of the amendment language.

Compound question

It’s a compound question that asks for one response to two propositions from the voters on the same referendum question. This compound formulation promotes ambiguity rendering the electorate’s ballot preference unknown because voters were only able to get to cast one yes or no to the two different questions.

As mentioned, this problem is addressed in the judiciary through the “single-subject test,” cited as the central question by the Wisconsin Court of Appeals (District IV) decision to certify the case to Wisconsin Supreme Court: “[Was] the marriage amendment (enacted) in violation of the single-subject rule set forth in Article XII, section 1 of the Wisconsin Constitution.”

Common sense

Let’s apply some common sense analysis vis a vis Dane County Circuit Judge Richard Niess.

As reported in The Capital Times:

In his ruling last year, Dane County Circuit Judge Richard Niess said McConkey could sue (and his case was not tossed, and so moved ahead). But he ruled the two clauses in the referendum question were ‘two sides of the same coin’ and properly decided with one vote.

‘They clearly relate to the same subject matter and further the same purpose: the preservation and protection of the unique and historical status of traditional marriage,’ he said in a ruling from the bench.
What in Sam’s hell you thinking, Judge Niess? That's the same conclusion reached by the religious right, J.B. Van Hollen and the GOP who put this referendum on the ballot in the first place: "(H)istorical status of traditional marriage" is a GOP talking point used to protect America from the gays.

There is no justification for Niess imputing a unitary coherence onto the religious right's compound formulation.

This would be like the GOP passing an amendment calling for banning evolution being taught in public schools and prohibiting sex education in the schools, and the Niess saying the questions are related because of they further 'the preservation and protection of the unique and historical status of traditional family values.'

The first part of the referendum question asks about one man-one woman and marriage.

The second part of the question asks about “unmarried individuals” not having relationships resembling a legal marriage without mention of any gender requirement of the individuals in question.

The second part of the question applies to relationships among unmarried individuals and constraints on the legal recognition of certain relationships between unmarried individuals of unspecified gender that “shall not be valid or recognized in this state.”

Do you think a voter could be in favor of the first question but not the second?

And since the voter is forced to answer both questions with one yes or no, that there might be a problem of ambiguity here with the formulation?

Judge Niess’ speculation

Furthermore, Judge Niess’ speculation that the legislative purpose of the amendment is the “preservation and protection of the unique and historical status of traditional marriage” is foolish (and astoundingly ignorant) in the face of the dynamic, evolving history of marriage.

Back to the formulation. Banning same sex marriage in the first proposition. But what happened to same sex exclusions in the second proposition? It’s not there and the propositions are two different subjects with two very different political histories and two different public policy effects.

If Niess wants to speculate on purpose, he would be more on target to assert the GOP and religious right want to punish gays with whom they have both a strange interest and enmity.

And on the second matter, the GOP's politics are very weird about society sanctioning relationships between unmarried individuals of any gender because of their particular mores or political objectives of the moment.

In any event, Niess’ ruling sent the case forward to an appeals court that certified it for Supreme Court hearing.

Let’s hope the Supreme Court invalidates this plain compound-question referendum and the shameful constitutional amendment that it brought us, and creates a judicial doctrine that would offer guidance in the future for clear judicial policymaking should we ever again elect a legislature foolish enough to send voters a compound question as a referendum again.