Showing posts with label Wisconsin voter ID trial lawsuit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wisconsin voter ID trial lawsuit. Show all posts

Oct 6, 2015

Wisconsin Voter ID Challenge Is Back on Track

Veterans will cheat on Election Day, implies
Scott Walker
Update: Oral arguments were heard April 7, 2016 at the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit for Frank v. Walker, (15-3582 Ruthelle Frank v. Scott Walker), arguing a narrower set of issues. One Wisconsin Institute v. Nichol (U.S. District Court of the Western District of Wisconsin (Case 15-cv-324)) is expected to got to trial in May or June 2016.

Update: Opinion and Order Denying Plaintiffs' Motion for Permanent Injunction and Class Certification, and Dismissing Remaining Claims (PDF) (filed 10/19/15)

Hope is back Wisconsin voters can defeat Republican-backed photo voter ID obstruction.

Updated - Voting rights plaintiffs argued in a hearing October 5, 2015 a legal motion, moving for a permanent injunction, class certification, and judgment on remaining claims against the Republican-enacted Voter ID statute in the case, Ruthelle Frank, et al., v. Scott Walker et al (No. 14A352).

Though the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the Frank (14-803) case in March, 2015 (MoritzLaw), yesterday's hearing in U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman's court breathes new life into the case. Adelman is a judge in the Eastern District of Wisconsin.

While Gov. Scott Walker tweeted yesterday, "Our photo ID law makes it easy to vote but hard to cheat," voting rights advocates argued the opposite on behalf of veterans, low-income, elderly, minority, college and vocational students.

Wisconsin's photo voter ID law was crafted by Republicans to allow only a narrow range of IDs as a condition to vote, even disallowing the use of U.S. Dept of Veterans Affairs (DVA) Veterans Health Identification Cards (VIC) (Mal Contends Sept. 2011; Mal Contends Nov. 2103; Mal Contends July 2012).

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) estimates that 49,933 veterans are homeless on any given night (National Coalition for Homeless Veterans). Many homeless veterans have VICs as their only means of identification.

The AP reported today, "Attorney Sean Young, of the ACLU Voting Rights Project, asked for the judge to make changes in time for the February [2016] primary. He said the law as written violates the Constitution's equal protection clause." (Moore, ABC News)

Since March 2015, voting rights plaintiffs have made a series of motions in Frank revealing a strategy to ensure citizens can vote, as Scott Walker and Republicans work diligently to stop voters.

"Photo IDs issued by the Department of Veteran Affairs ... are not acceptable photo ID for voting purposes," is language no longer on the Wisconsin Government Accountability Board Voter Photo ID Law-Frequently Asked Questions informational site, though this language was displayed in September 2011 (Mal Contends).

Another case against Wisconsin voter obstruction laws, One Wisconsin Institute v. Nichol, continues in the Western District of Wisconsin. The complaint was filed in May 2015.

Mar 23, 2015

Wisconsin Voter ID Law Challenge Gets No Hearing Before Supreme Court

Updated - Wisconsin case assists GOP efforts to block voters likely to oppose the GOP

Voter Photo ID is law of the land in Wisconsin - Implementation will begin AFTER the Spring General Election on April 7

Update II: "Our legal team did an outstanding job defending Wisconsin law, from the trial court to the U.S. Supreme Court. Absentee ballots are already in the hands of voters, therefore, the law cannot be implemented for the April 7 election. The Voter ID law will be in place for future elections – this decision is final."—Wisconsin Attorney General Brad Schimel

Update: It is possible that the four 'liberal' justices on the Court torpedoed this challenge to Wisconsin's Voter ID out of concern the five rightwing activist justices on the Court are looking to further slice off section(s) of what remains of the the Voting Rights Act. This suggests that the five GOP justices are so off-the-charts hostile to the Voting Rights Act, (enacted to enforce the Fifteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, and for other purposes), that a radical policy of further disfranchisement is coming in the future, should the five GOP justices remain on the Court.
 ---
The U.S. Supreme Court decided this morning to reject a challenge by civil rights activists to Wisconsin's Photo Voter ID law.

The cases, Walker v. Frank (and a consolidated case), will not be reviewed by the Court, a refusal to hear a Photo Voter ID law on the merits in the first major challenge before the Court since Crawford v. Marion County Election Board (Indiana) (2008), a state-specific and content-specific opinion.

The Court will not rule whether Wisconsin's restrictive Photo Voter ID law abridges the right to vote without justification in violation of the U.S. Constitution's Equal Protection Clause and the Voting Rights Act, Section 2.

Republicans nationwide have used Voter ID laws and other laws to target the disabled, minorities, classes of the elderly and young voters who have trended heavily Democratic in their voting patterns.

As noted in SCOTUSBlog, at issue in the Frank case is "Whether a state’s voter ID law violates the Equal Protection Clause where, unlike in Crawford v. Marion County Election Board, the evidentiary record establishes that the law substantially burdens the voting rights of hundreds of thousands of the state’s voters, and that the law does not advance a legitimate state interest; and (2) whether a state’s voter ID law violates Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act where the law disproportionately burdens and abridges the voting rights of African-American and Latino voters compared to White voters."

Wisconsin's Voter ID law was upheld by the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in a heavily criticized opinion by Judge Frank Easterbrook on October 6, 2014 issued after voting had already begun in the 2014 general Fall election. Judge Easterbrook's decision is now operative.

The Voter ID law was enjoined days later after an order by the U.S. Supreme Court (now terminated) issued on October 9, 2014, (Mal Contends) reinstating U.S. District Judge Lynn Adelman's decision and order issuing a permanent injunction on April 29, 2014.

After the Supreme Court order, Wisconsin's Republican attorney general at the time, J.B. Van Hollen, issued a statement contradicting the Court order, saying Wisconsin will "have voter ID on election day" in another GOP effort to confuse and mislead voters. (Mal Contends and Hall, Wisconsin State Journal) Van Hollen later backed away from his statement.

Frank v. Walker also features the extraordinary development of the federal appellate court's Judge Richard Posner's call for a rehearing of the Frank decision on October 10, 2014, a suggestion that failed five-to-five.

What is significant in Posner's 43-page request is the meticulous language in which Posner "includes a devastating response to virtually every false and/or disingenuous rightwing argument/talking point ever put forth in support of Photo ID voting restrictions, describing them as 'a mere fig leaf for efforts to disenfranchise voters likely to vote for the political party that does not control the state government,'" as noted by the legal-political writer Brad Friedman and other legal scholars across the nation. (Mal Contends)

Posner is the author of the 2007 appellate court decision upholding Indiana's Voter ID law in Crawford.

Posner in 2013 states that "data" and "evidence" on the consequences of judicial opinions ought help to guide appellate decisions on the constitutionality of state Voter Id laws, and other judicial decisions. (Posner, The New Republic)

The author of the 2008 U.S. Supreme Court opinion on Crawford, Justice John Paul Stevens (1975-2010), has also issued a statement after he retired in which he takes issue with Voter ID laws as a means of obstructing voters (Bravin, Wall Street Journal and Josh Blackman) and with the Court's evisceration of the Voting Rights Act in 2013. (Cohen, The Atlantic)

Jan 26, 2015

Wisconsin GOP Rising Star Caught in Voter Fraud—Distributing Misinformation

Unable to produce any cases of in-person voter fraud in Wisconsin, the Republican Party of Wisconsin was forced to commit voter fraud, though a different kind.

Chris Liebenthal has the story.

Milwaukee County Supervisor Deanna Alexander, a rising star among Wisconsin Republicans, willfully informed her constituents that photo voter ID would be needed to vote, knowing fully well that this is not the case in Wisconsin.

Judge Richard Posner of the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit notes this is the voter fraud known as intentional "Misinformation" in his dissent in Ruthelle Frank v. Scott Walker (On Suggestion of Rehearing En Banc, October 20, 2014) (p. 12).

Posner's offers a "nonexhaustive" list of voter fraud, citing Voter Fraud Facts.

One hopes this crime is investigated and criminal charges are filed.

Oct 9, 2014

US Supreme Court Halts Wisconsin Voter ID Law

Ruthelle Frank of Brokaw, Wisconsin fights for
her right to vote against Scott Walker and
the Republican Party
In a victory of civil rights advocate, the US Supreme Court has ordered that Wisconsin's restrictive photo voter ID law is not to be enforced in the November election.

This means photo voter ID is not necessary for registered Wisconsin voters to cast votes.

The order is a defeat for Wisconsin Republicans who targeted the disabled, minorities, classes of the elderly and young voters who have trended heavily Democratic in their voting patterns.

These voters are more apt to not have the restrictive range of IDs Republicans crafted in their legislation, Act 23.

The case is Ruthelle Frank, et al., Applicants v. Scott Walker et al (No. 14A352).

Here is the opinion (from Rick Hasen's Election Law Blog); Justices Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas dissented.

The state of Texas' restrictive Voter ID law was also struck down this evening by a U.S. District Court judge.

The Advancement Project celebrates voting rights victory.
Earlier today, attorney Katherine Culliton-González of the Advancement Project expressed confidence, saying, voting rights advocates have an "exceedingly strong case on the facts and the law" to vacate or nullify the stay by the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

The Opinions read:

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
No. 14A352
RUTHELLE FRANK, ET AL .v. SCOTT WALKER ET AL.
ON APPLICATION TO VACATE STAY
[October 9, 2014]
The application to vacate the September 12, 2014 order of the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit presented to Justice Kagan and by her referred to the Court is granted and the Seventh Circuit’s stay of the district court’s permanent injunction is vacated pending the timely filing and disposition of a petition for a writ of certiorari respecting case Nos. 14-2058 & 14-2059. Should the petition for a writ of certiorari be denied, this order shall terminate automatically. In the event the petition for a writ of certiorari is granted, the order shall terminate upon the sending down of the judgment of this Court
---

JUSTICE ALITO, with whom JUSTICE SCALIA and JUSTICE THOMAS join, dissenting.
There is a colorable basis for the Court’s decision due to the proximity of the upcoming general election. It is particularly troubling that absentee ballots have been sent out without any notation that proof of photo identification must be submitted. But this Court “may not vacate a stay entered by a court of appeals unless that court clearly and ‘demonstrably’ erred in its application of ‘accepted standards.’”
Planned Parenthood of Greater Tex. Surgical Health Servs. v. Abbott, 571 U. S. ___, ___ (2013) (slip op.,at 1)
(SCALIA, J., concurring in denial of application to vacate stay) (quoting Western Airlines, Inc. v. Teamsters,480 U. S. 1301, 1305 (1987) (O’Connor, J., in chambers); some internal quotation marks omitted). Under that test, the application in this case should be denied.

US Supreme Court Ruling on Wisconsin Voter ID Expected Within Forty-eight Hours

Wisconsin voting rights advocates have an "exceedingly strong case on the facts and the law" to vacate or nullify the stay by the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, said Katherine Culliton-González this morning, freeing Wisconsin voters to cast their votes without presenting a restrictive range of voter IDs.

Culliton-González is co-counsel to the League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) of Wisconsin, co-plaintiffs in the Wisconsin civil rights cases now before the US Supreme Court.

Culliton-González works for the Advancement Project as Senior Attorney and Director of Voter Protection.

An emergency petition (application) was filed with Justice Kagan, but sources close to the litigation said they expect the petition to be heard by the full Court.

If Kagan were to vacate the stay, then Republican Wisconsin Attorney General Van Hollen could and likely would then file another emergency petition (application) to another justice, under US Supreme Court rules.

Van Hollen and Scott Walker want the Wisconsin Voter ID law in effect on Election Day to disenfranchise as many minority and young voters as possible, increasing Scott Walker's chance for reelection

Culliton-González pointed to the many cases supporting voter rights advocates following the Pursell principle of federal courts never changing the rules of an election after an election has begun or close to an election, a principle that emphatically applies to Voter ID cases and in Wisconsin where the appellate panel ruled after the election had begun.

Check at Election Law Blog and Ruthelle Frank v. Scott Walker for updates.

Oct 8, 2014

Waiting for Kagan

Updated - Hundreds of thousands of voters and those who care about them are waiting on the Emergency application now before US Supreme Court Justice Kagan to restore the status quo, and rid Wisconsin of its restrictive Photo Voter ID law while the election is ongoing and adjudication continues.

Republicans hope for a favorable ruling from Kagan to block as many young and minority voters as possible. Other Wisconsin citizens caught in the voter obstruction net are a price the Republican Party is willing to inflict.

Election experts say a ruling could come at any time.

So we wait, and wait.

Check at Election Law Blog and Ruthelle Frank v. Scott Walker for updates.

The ACLU, one of a host of civil liberties groups fighting voter obstruction law, released a press release blasting the opinion of the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

WASHINGTON — The American Civil Liberties Union today asked the U.S. Supreme Court to stay Monday's ruling from a Seventh Circuit appeals panel that concluded Wisconsin's voter ID law is constitutional and does not violate the Voting Rights Act. 

 The following is a statement from Dale Ho, director of the ACLU's Voting Rights Project:

 "Permitting this law to go into effect so close to the election is fueling voter confusion and election chaos in Wisconsin, particularly for the many voters who have already cast their ballots. Voters deserve a fair shake, and this last-minute disruption changes the rules of the game in an election that is already underway, and risks locking out thousands of voters. The stakes are extremely high."

 The motion filed today also notes factual inaccuracies in the appeals panel's ruling, including:

- "The Seventh Circuit also could not fathom that so many registered Wisconsin voters lack a photo ID 'in a world in which photo ID is essential to board an airplane, . . . pick up a prescription at a pharmacy, open a bank account or cash a check at a currency exchange, buy a gun, or enter a courthouse to serve as a juror or watch the argument of this appeal.' Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, and wrong again. Wisconsin fliers, patients, bank customers, gun owners, and court watchers do not need photo IDs. Only Wisconsin voters."
 
- "The panel inexplicably stated that key voter witnesses 'did not testify that they had tried to get [a copy of their birth certificate], let alone that they had tried but failed.' But numerous witnesses testified that they tried and failed to get a birth certificate so they could get a voter ID."
The ACLU, the ACLU of Wisconsin, the National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty, and Dechert LLP are co-counsel in this case, Frank v. Walker.

 A copy of the full motion is available here.

Oct 7, 2014

Van Hollen Jumps the Shark in Last-Ditch Effort to Preserve Wisconsin Voter ID

Here is another ludicrous element of the J.B. Van Hollen's last-ditch effort to preserve Wisconsin's photo voter ID law, imposed after voting had begun.

Van Hollen adopts Frank Easterbrook's "chutzpah-filled argument that it would cause voter confusion to undo the confusion caused by the 7th Circuit’s surprise order," notes Rick Hasan, election law expert.

But there's more.

Writes Van Hollen's brief:
Wisconsin’s widest-circulated newspaper declared shortly after the denial of en banc rehearing that, “The voter ID issue is settled—at least for the Nov. 4. election: Voters will be required to bring a photo ID to the polls.”
Van Hollen cites a Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel editorial, "Don't let voter ID law stop you from voting on Nov. 4" from Sept. 28, 2014.

Since Sept 28, there have been at least two news pieces prominently mentioning the Emergency petition (application) pending before U.S. Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan:

So, to believe Van Hollen, we are to accept that a Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel editorial written before major news pieces in the same daily has now confused Wisconsin voters.

Kagan is expected to rule soon; and likely either ask for more briefing, rule for voting rights advocates against the obstruction law, or throw the matter to whole Court (bad for voting rights advocates).

Or, Kagan could deny the  Emergency petition (application). Crazier things have happened.

Absurd Position from Wisconsin Attorney General Van Hollen

Update: Read Rick Hasen's commentary on Van Hollen's response brief. Decision could be announced any moment.
---
Wisconsin's Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen released a statement yesterday, saying because Judge Frank Easterbrook released the appellate Court's opinion yesterday, 29 days before Election Day, this "decision on the merits provides greater certainty that Wisconsin citizens will have the election in November that they expected three years ago -- one with Voter ID."

Who knew the Wisconsin electorate was so in tune with the opinions from the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit?

I thought it was just scholars, writers and voting rights activists.

Van Hollen is trying to get past the Purcell principle that says federal court decisions shy away from elections close to beginning (Wisconsin's had already begun) lest chaos ensues and voters become disenfranchised.

Easterbrook rushed out an opinion, appalling and disingenuous as it is, to assist J.B. Van Hollen's response to the Emergency application now before US Supreme Court Justice Kagen.

Van Hollen's response is due at 5:00 pm (Eastern time).

Wisconsin's corrupt Republican attorney general will assure Justice Kagen everything is clear in Wisconsin now.

Easterbrook reinstated Wisconsin Voter ID law on Sept. 12 after Wisconsin's election had already begun, votes had already been cast and chaos became the defining characteristic to the point that one in five Wisconsin citizens still say have no idea they need voter ID.

One hopes Kagen will not buy Van Hollen's absurd argument, and at least partially vacate Easterbrook's stay on the injunction of Wisconsin voter obstruction law that Scott Walker needs in place to win in November.

Jul 31, 2014

Wisconsin Voter ID Law Upheld Four-to Three in Repudiation of Wisconsin Voting Guarantees

Appalling, corrupt decision dispels myth of impartial Court

The photo voter ID decision is posted on Wisconsin Supreme Court page.

The law remains unenforceable due to a federal injunction in two consolidated federal cases against the law.

Other major decisions issued today can be found here at Court page.

There can be no doubt that Wisconsin Republican Party's de facto four partisan justices on the Wisconsin Supreme Court are either removed from the reality of 100,000s of Wisconsin citizens or more likely just issued a corrupt partisan decision, salvaging the photo voter ID law.

Wrote Justice Patience Roggensack in the four-three opinion: "In the present case, we conclude that the burdens of time and inconvenience associated with obtaining Act 23-acceptable photo identification are not undue burdens on the right to vote and do not render the law invalid."

Wisconsin's Constitutional guarantee to vote is so expansive that in the 19th century, it took a Constitutional amendment to mandate registration of voters.

The point is that "state constitutions explicitly grant the right to vote to state citizens," as Joshua A. Douglas notes in the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel.

Thankfully Wisconsin's two U.S. attorneys (the top law enforcement officials in their respective districts) along with U.S. Attorney General Holder have defended the right to vote against this Republican voter obstruction effort.

Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson' dissent reads in part: "Today the court follows no James Madison--for whom Wisconsin's capital city is named--but rather Jim Crow," noted the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin in a statement..

Writes Abrahamson: "Act 23's photo identification requirements severely burden eligible voters without being narrowly tailored to achieve the state's compelling interests of reducing voter fraud and increasing voter confidence in the outcomes of elections.  For that reason, Act 23 is an unconstitutional election regulation, and I therefore respectfully dissent."

The rationale of Act 23 is to block as many Democratically leaning voters as possible from casting votes.

“Rather than blocking thousands of eligible citizens from voting, we should be working to ensure that our elections are free, fair and accessible to all eligible Wisconsin voters,” said Andrea Kaminski of the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin in a statement.

This is a result-oriented decision that purposely misapplies a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision, Crawford v. Indiana and ignores the guarantee to vote in the Wisconsin Constitution, and the long history of case law recognizing this guarantee.

Never in Wisconsin judicial history has there been this type of corrupt decision that attacks the foundation of the state of Wisconsin as a political entity.

Jul 30, 2014

Three Huge Civil Rights Rulings to Be Released Thursday Morning in Wisconsin

Update: In other legal news, another of Scott Walker's attempts to grab power, Walker's judicial ally's halting the John Doe probe looking into the criminal scheme of which Walker was central, is set to be heard in oral arguments on September 9 before a three-judge panel of the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. U.S. District Judge Rudolph Randa halted the John Doe probe in early May in Eric O’Keefe and Wisconsin Club for Growth, Inc. v Francis Schmitz.

Also, the U.S. "Department of Justice today intervened in the ACLU of Wisconsin voting rights case, filing an amicus brief in opposition to the voter ID law," the ACLU reports.

The Wisconsin Supreme Court is poised to make three historic rulings on Photo Voter ID (Act 23); Act 10 curtailing freedom to form public workers' unions; and the law codifying right of same-sex couples to receive domestic partner benefits. (Stein, Ferguson, Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel)

The cases are:
  • League of Women Voters of Wisconsin Education Network, Inc. v. Scott Walker, et al. combined with Milwaukee Branch of the NAACP v. Scott Walker
  • Madison Teachers, Inc. v. Scott Walker
  • Julaine K. Appling, et al. v. James E. Doyle, et al
All of the cases represent part of Scott Walker and the right wing's legislative attempt to codify the authority of their temporary partisan majority in the legislative and executive branch to take away rights and political power of disfavored citizens.

The cases' opinions can be found at the "Today's Released Supreme Court Opinions" link on Thursday between 8:00 a.m. and 8:45 a.m. Central Time, barring any technical difficulties, according to a clerk reached at the Wisconsin Supreme Court this morning.

Most observers predict the Court will strike down the photo Voter ID law because of Wisconsin's expansive protection of the right to vote.

Act 10 curtailing the right to form public unions will likely be upheld by the four-three right wing Court majority.

And I have no idea what the Court will do with the domestic partnership statute signed into law by Gov. Jim Doyle on June 29, 2009.

May 16, 2014

Wisconsin Attorney General Refuses to Defend Constitutional Law Enforcement Officers

Wisconsin Attorney General
refuses to defend Constitutional
law enforcement officers
As the Republican Party works to stop the bipartisan John Doe investigation looking into possible issue ad coordination between the Scott Walker campaign, (and likely Wisconsin state senate campaigns), and numerous groups that ran issue ads in the 2012 recall elections, U.S. District Judge Rudolph Randa ruled that "[Wisconsin] regulations and statutes" do not apply to the groups subpoenaed in the investigation, thus no John Doe probe may continue.

Randa's is an absurdly activist and corrupt decision, heavily criticized among jurists.

Randa has stepped in the middle of a law enforcement investigation conducted by Wisconsin constitutional officers (district attorneys, Article VI, section 4) who are empowered by Wisconsin statutes to conduct John Doe probes in specific circumstances.

Attorney General J. B. Van Hollen should be attempting to intervene in Eric O’Keefe and Wisconsin Club for Growth, Inc. v Francis Schmitz, et al. (Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel document) and defend Wisconsin constitutional officers in their criminal justice investigation.

The fact that Van Hollen is sitting this case out speaks to the fact that Van Hollen feels his duty is to the Republican Party of Wisconsin and not the people and Constitution of Wisconsin.

When Van Hollen feels his party is threatened by litigation, Van Hollen's Department of Justice (DoJ) has no hesitation constructing any argument no matter the effect on the rights of Wisconsin citizens, if the DoJ would prevail.

Consider Van Hollen's effort to try to stay the injunction against Wisconsin's photo voter ID law, Act 23, designed to obstruct Wisconsin voters (Frank v. Walker; League of United Latin American Citizens of Wisconsin v. Deininger).

Writes Van Hollen and the Wisconsin DoJ in a May 2014 motion to keep the GOP-crafted voter ID operative for the next election: “‘[A]ny time a State is enjoined by a court from effectuating statutes enacted by representatives of its people, it suffers a form of  irreparable injury’” [Maryland v. King, ___ U.S. ___, 133 S. Ct. 1, 3 (2012)] (other citations omitted).

If Van Hollen truly feels this way, why is he not blasting away at Judge Randa in court and in the press?

May 13, 2014

Wisconsin Attorney General Is Just Another GOP Hack

Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen is again using his office in service to the Republican Party of Wisconsin, instead of the people of Wisconsin.

It doesn't have to be this way.

Yesterday, Van Hollen appealed Wisconsin Federal District Judge Lynn Adelman's order and opinion finding Wisconsin photo voter ID law violates the U.S. Constitution and Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act.

The appeal will heard by the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit.

Van Hollen could refuse to defend the unconstitutional law that after a November 2013 trial that showed that Wisconsin Act 23 could disenfranchise as many as 300,000 Wisconsin voters, among them minorities, the elderly, disaffected veterans, students, technical college students and those who have recently moved their residences.

Newspapers, some of which are GOP-leaning in their editorial pages, have urged Van Hollen to stop wasting money and time defending a law intended to make it more difficult for Wisconsin citizens to vote, in furtherance of the careers of Republican Party officeholders.

Van Hollen's decision comes as no surprise as he vowed to appeal in early May, nor does Scott Walker, James Sensenbrenner and the Republican Party's tenacious pursuit and abiding support of blocking Wisconsin voters from voting.

It bears repeating that in 2008 Van Hollen tried to use the Help America Vote Act to suppress Democratically leaning voters to stave off landslide defeat for the McCain-Palin ticket of which Van Hollen served as co-chair.

In 2008, WisPolitics uncovered an audio recording revealing Van Hollen promising such action on during the Republican National Convention held in St. Paul, Minnesota, after multiple conversations with Reince Priebus, then Wisconsin GOP party chairman, after Van Hollen denied holding secret conversations on the suit with Republican officials.

"(T)here was no discussion with anybody involved in leadership with the Republican Party (or the McCain campaign) about this (voting rule) lawsuit before it was brought," Van Hollen said.

WisPolitics blew that lie out of the water after uncovering audio of Van Hollen talking with the Republican leadership promising legal action in a corruption of his office.

Though Republicans often contend that state photo voter ID laws have been found constitutional in Crawford vs. Marion County Elections Board (2008) by the U.S. Supreme Court, Earnest A. Canning knocked down this contention in his piece from early May in the Brad Blog.

Canning's analysis is required reading for anyone reporting on the GOP voter obstruction and photo voter ID laws.

Writes Canning:
In 2006, Indiana Republicans enacted the first such polling place Photo ID law in the nation. That case made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court in Crawford vs. Marion County Elections Board (2008), before it was allowed to be enforced by the state.
 
The Court's ruling in the case, however, was far different from how Republican defenders of such laws have portrayed it ever since, including Texas Attorney General (and Gubernatorial candidate) Greg Abbot, who falsely claimed last year, in response to the U.S. Dept. of Justice's lawsuit against his state's similar law, that "The U.S. Supreme Court has already ruled that voter ID laws do not suppress legal votes." In fact, the Court did no such thing.
 
As this site, and numerous others, have repeatedly noted, Crawford involved the allegation that Indiana's first-in-the-nation Photo ID voting restriction was unconstitutional "on its face." Six of the U.S. Supreme Court's nine Justices rejected that facial challenge, but they decidedly did not, as Abbot incorrectly declared, find that "voter ID laws do not suppress legal votes."
 
What they did do, however, is establish the test that must be applied to such laws in determining their constitutionality. At the core of his decision in the Wisconsin case, Judge Adelman applied that test with careful measure.
 
As Judge Adelman observed, Crawford lacked a "majority opinion" --- that is an opinion in which five Justices agreed on the reasons for the decision. Instead, there were four separate opinions: a lead opinion written by Justice John Paul Stevens (joined by Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Kennedy), a concurring opinion written by Justice Antonin Scalia (joined by Justices Thomas and Alito), a dissenting opinion written by Justice David Souter (joined by Justice Ginsburg) and a separate dissent by Justice Breyer.
 
While the various Justices agreed and disagreed on a number of points throughout those opinions, Judge Adelman notes that six of the nine Justices each concurred that the correct approach is to apply what he describes as the Anderson/Burdick test, which requires the courts, on a case-by-case basis, to measure a law's potential damage to voters' right to vote, against the specific claims made by the state as to why such additional burdens and restrictions are necessary.
 
"Even very slight burdens," he wrote, "'must be justified by relevant and legitimate state interests 'sufficiently weighty to justify the limitation.'"
 
In fact, all nine Justices in Crawford agreed that the Anderson/Burdick balancing test applied in the case. The difference between the dissenting opinions and the lead opinion written by Justice Stevens is based exclusively on their respective views on the status of the actual evidence on record before the Court.
 
In his dissent, Justice Souter opined that the Hoosier State's polling place Photo ID law "threatens to impose nontrivial burdens on the voting right of tens of thousands of the State's citizens...and a significant percentage of those individuals are likely to be deterred from voting."
 
In comments to The BRAD BLOG last October, Bill Groth, attorney for the lead plaintiff in the Crawford case, insisted that he had, in fact, presented an adequate record of undue burden on voters in the case. Justice Stevens, however, didn't see it that way. In his lead opinion, the now-retired Justice observed that "the evidence in the record does not provide us with the number of registered voters without photo identification." He found there was no "concrete evidence of the burden imposed on voters who currently lack photo identification" and reasoned that, based upon the record before the Court, they "cannot conclude that the statute imposes 'excessively burdensome requirements' on any class of voters."
 
The Court did not find that Indiana's law imposed no burden on voters, as Abbott in Texas, and Republicans elsewhere have attempted to claim, but rather, such evidence had simply not been presented to the Court in that case.
 
In October 2013, after Circuit Court Judge Richard Posner, during a book-tour interview, essentially recanted his original majority opinion in the Crawford case --- the one that eventually landed before the Supreme Court. Posner admitted he'd gotten it wrong. Justice Stevens, who retired in 2010, was then asked about his own lead opinion in the case, and told the Wall Street Journal, that he "always thought that [dissenter] David Souter got the thing correct, but my own problem with the case was that I didn't think the record [before the Court at the time] supported everything he said in his opinion."
 
Crawford, Stevens insists, "is state-specific and record-specific." Meaning, the Court's ruling was based on, and applied only to Indiana's version of the law, how it was implemented there, how it affected voters in that particular state, and what information on all of the above was available in the record before the court at the time.

May 2, 2014

Wisconsin AG Van Hollen Vows to Seek Stay of Decision Halting Voter ID

Update: Worth noting is that state voter ID laws meant to obstruct voters (in a sick irony) would be specifically protected by H.R. 3899, the Voting Rights Act Amendment (VRAA), introduced by Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-White People). The Voting Rights Act was first enacted in 1965 to "enforce the fifteenth amendment to the Constitution of the United States, and for other purposes."

The Fifteenth Amendment reads in part, the "right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any state on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude."

Progressive Democrats, such as Rep. Mark Pocan (D-Madison) are hoping against hope that Speaker John Boehner will suddenly become amiable to amendments to take out the language of the VRAA that makes HR 3899 a steaming pile of very toxic and fetid waste. See this bizarre March 27, 2014 letter by House Democrats that in part reads "some of us believe the bill should be enacted in its current form, and some of us prefer to see it amended" in an appeal to John Boehner. This is the same John Boehner who said during the 2012 campaign that he hopes Latinos and Blacks do not show up and vote. (Reeve, August 27, 2012; Yahoo News) at a Christian Science Monitor luncheon.

Meanwhile, Sensenbrenner was caught on camera in February saying, "I hope the president vetoes the bill. If the president vetoes—well, let me rephrase that – if the president vetoes this bill, he will lose an awful lot of the African-American support that he has." (Roth. TRMS)

Anybody really doubt where Republicans like Sensenbrenner and Boehner stand on voting rights?

What if this anti-voter VRAA actually passes Congress? Did House Democrats consider this scenario?

Dumb, dumb, dumb.
---
Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen has learned a lot from Scott Walker in service to the Republican Party while ripping off the Wisconsin people.

Make up statements and don't back them up with facts.

For some three years during Walker's tenure Van Hollen has been using the attorney general's office in service to the Republican Party, and Van Hollen typically throws out fact-free lines for reporters' consumption.

Now, Van Hollen's office says Federal Judge Lynn Adelman's decision barring enforcement of Act 23 is "flawed," and the Wisconsin DoJ with Walker's blessing will seek a stay, vacating the permanent injunction. (Hall, Wisconsin State Journal)

What's flawed about the Adelman's decision? Van Hollen won't say.

But Van Hollen and Walker, with Rep. James Sensenbrenner's help, keep up their GOP-crafted-law-is-common sense and "constitutional" lines of malarkey.

Writes Adelman:
The evidence at trial established that virtually no voter impersonation occurs in Wisconsin. The defendants could not point to a single instance of known voter impersonation occurring in Wisconsin at any time in the recent past. ...

Some have suggested that voter fraud might be more widespread than the low number of prosecutions indicates because the laws that prohibit voter fraud are under enforced. However, the defendants do not suggest that there is any underenforcement of such laws in Wisconsin. And the evidence at trial indicates that such laws are vigorously enforced (citations omitted by me).
What do Walker and Van Hollen and the Republicans say to this? Nothing.

Local conservative, William R. Wineke, has something to say today, Republicans should listen. Writes Wineke at Channel 3000 (WISC TV):
Ever since Republicans took control of state governments around the country in 2010, they have thrown conservative principles out the window.

They keep passing laws to limit abortions and keep trying to pass laws that would outlaw some forms of birth control and force women who become pregnant from rapes or incest to bear their rapists’ children.

They use the power of state governments to interfere with the rights of local governments. Want to pass a minimum wage law for Milwaukee? Let’s strip the right of municipalities to do that.

But the voting rights thing is the big one. We all know why our state wants voter ID It’s because the governor and legislators who gained power through the ballot box want to make sure no one can take that power away from them through the ballot box.

That may be good politics, but it sure isn’t conservative.
No, it's not. Stopping Americans from voting is unAmerican.

Trying to stop Americans from voting is typical Van Hollen, and is a Republican mission. Recall Van Hollen's corrupt use of office in 2008, for example.

Van Hollen tried to use the Help America Vote Act to suppress Democratically leaning voters to stave off a landslide defeat for the McCain-Palin ticket of which he served as co-chair, an effort thrown out of court never to see light again.

In 2008, WisPolitics uncovered an audio recording revealing Van Hollen promising action on alleged "voter fraud" during an address at the Republican National Convention held in St. Paul, Minnesota, after multiple conversations with Reince Priebus, then Wisconsin GOP party chairman.

The fact that there is no voter fraud is of no concern in GOP land.

Said Wisconsin candidate for attorney general, Ismael Ozanne in April about Van Hollen's 2008 scheme: "The ethical concern is serving as campaign chair and then taking official actions as attorney general that are intended to benefit the campaign in question, and not reflecting the law and the best interests of the people of Wisconsin.  If AG Van Hollen thought it was necessary in his official capacity to participate in legal action involving the campaign, he should have either stepped down from any role in the campaign or recused himself from the legal action."

Van Hollen, Walker and the Republicans should spend their time trying to help Americans vote, not attempting to prevent Americans from voting.

Apr 30, 2014

Voter ID Law Struck Down, Exposed Again As GOP Scheme to Obstruct Voters

Update: See also Exorcising the Voter Fraud Ghost (Hasen, Reuters), and A Federal Judge Searches for Voter Fraud in Wisconsin and Finds None (Cohen, The Atlantic), GOP’s Voter ID Sham Shot Down: Why a Federal Court Said No Way (Friedman, Salon), and Voter I.D. Is the Real Fraud (New York Times editorial, April 29, 2014).

It didn't take long for Assembly Speaker Robin Vos (Rochester, Wisconsin) and Scott Walker's office to declare their intentions to call a special session of the legislature to "do whatever it takes to ensure voter ID is in place as quickly as possible," in Vos' words to stop voter fraud.

This is of course a lie; there is no in-person voter fraud in Wisconsin and the media ought to report this fact. 

When Republicans assert voter fraud, they should be held accountable in the news against facts.

The real story is: Republicans are lying and trying relentlessly to stop legal voters from voting. This is an affront to democracy.

Fortunately for Wisconsin, the GOP's obstructive scheme of voter ID, Act 23, is stopped dead in its tracks.

These two cases Judge Lynn Adelman ruled on will take years to get to the U.S. Supreme Court.

In the mean time, the GOP should be held accountable, and its efforts to obstruct the vote of Wisconsin citizens should be reported on and condemned.

From Wisconsin Federal District Judge Lynn Adelman's opinion:

"The evidence introduced by the plaintiffs confirms that voter-impersonation fraud does not occur in Wisconsin. The plaintiffs offered the testimony of Lorraine Minnite, a professor at Rutgers University who specializes in the study of the incidence of voter fraud in contemporary American elections. Professor Minnite studied elections in Wisconsin during the years 2004, 2008, 2010 and 2012 to determine whether she could identify any incidents of voter fraud. She consulted a variety of sources of information, including newspaper databases, news releases by the Wisconsin Attorney General, criminal complaints, decisions by state courts, and documents issued by the GAB. From these sources, Minnite was able to identify only one case of voter-impersonation fraud. Tr. 1036–42. And the single case of voter-impersonation fraud did not involve in-person voter impersonation. Rather, that case involved a man who applied for and cast his recently deceased wife’s absentee ballot. Tr. 1041. Thus, from Minnite’s work, it appears that there have been zero incidents of in-person voter-impersonation fraud in Wisconsin during recent elections."

Apr 29, 2014

Wisconsin Voter ID Law Struck Down in Federal Court, Permanent Injunction Granted

"IT IS ORDERED that the named Defendants and Defendants’ officers, agents, servants, employees, and attorneys, and all those acting in concert or participation with them, or having actual or implicit knowledge of this Order by
personal service or otherwise, are hereby permanently enjoined from conditioning a person’s access to a ballot, either in-person or absentee, on that person’s presenting a form of photo identification."
- Wisconsin Federal District Judge Lynn Adelman

Wow.

A November 2013 voting rights trial has resulted in a crushing victory for voting rights activists against the Republican Party and Scott Walker in an opinion issued today in Wisconsin by Federal District Judge Lynn Adelman.

Rick Hasan has an early analysis up.

Feb 25, 2014

GOP-leaning Justice: 'I'm troubled by having to pay the state to vote"

Justice Patience  Roggensack
In the oral arguments in the Milwaukee Branch of the NAACP v. Walker et al (one of two cases heard today in the Wisconsin Supreme Court) challenging Wisconsin's Photo Voter ID law, Act 23), Justice Patience D. Roggensack took a skeptical tone against Assistant Attorney General Clayton Patrick Kawski in referencing the documentation those without GOP-prescribed ID would have to acquire and the money they would have to spend.

Roggensack appeared incredulous in stating that paying money to the state is necessary to vote.

Here is a transcription of the comment and question made to Assistant Attorney General Kawski defending Act 23 in court:
My concern is that for someone who doesn't have a birth certificate, there has to be a payment made to get that birth certificate [to get a license or acceptable ID and then be qualified to vote].

Now, it may not apply to me, I already have a driver's license. But anybody that doesn't have a birth certificate, it appears from the statute [Act 23] that there's a requirement that they make a payment, and the payment goes to the state.

And what bothers me is that this feels—although not universally as was the case in Harper (Harper v. Virginia Board of Elections (1966)) where there was $1.50 poll tax—it's still a payment to the state to be able to vote. That bothers me. Can you address that? ... I'm troubled by having to pay the state to vote.
The two cases heard are League of Women Voters of Wisconsin v. Walker et al and Milwaukee Branch of the NAACP v. Walker et al.

Two cases challenging Act 23 are being deliberated in federal court as well, and plaintiffs are seeking an injunction in those cases: Frank v. Walker, (Case 11cv1128) and League of United Latin American Citizens of Wisconsin v. Deininger (Case 2:12-cv-00185).

Don't "Destroy" the Right to Vote, Say Voting Rights Attorneys

Voting Rights Wars Still with Us, GOP Targets Voting

"'My concern is frankly trying to find a way that no one has to pay the state to vote if they don’t have what they need (to vote),' said Justice Roggensack, who often is noted as the leader of the conservative-leaning block of the court." (Heisig. Wisconsin Law Journal)

Updated - Oral Arguments on Wisconsin's Voter ID law today drew aggressive questioning that is typical of justices playing devil's advocate in elucidating the positions of the two sides, pro-voting v. anti-voting.

Make no mistake, Wisconsin Act 23, the Photo Voter ID law, is narrowly crafted to obstruct Wisconsin voters, aimed at sections of the electorate to aide a partisan outcome in favor of the Republicans, at the expense of constitutionally qualified, registered voters.

Such a partisan motive, however did not enter the discussion today, but was implied.

Some observations from viewing today's orals.

Attorney Lester Pines appearing for the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin v. Walker et al, argued that the authority of the state legislature to regulate elections does not include the power to draft legislation determining "who may vote," demanding a situation where constitutionally qualified, registered voters would walk to the polling table and in effect be asked "papers, please."

Pines called voting a "fundamental right," imperiled by Act 23, that was passed on a strict-party line vote within a half year after Scott Walker assumed office.

Richard Saks appearing for the Milwaukee Branch of the NAACP v. Walker et al took a similar position to Pines, noting that zero voter impersonation fraud cases have been prosecuted, while some 10 percent of Wisconsin citizens are estimated not to possess the GOP-crafted, narrow range of acceptable Photo voter IDs under Act 23.

Assistant Attorney General Clayton Patrick Kawski argued for the state of Wisconsin.

Kawski faced tough questioning from Justice Ann Walsh Bradley who said she found that if 10 percent of Wisconsin citizens could not legally vote because of Act 23, this is "breathtaking."

Bradley pummeled Kawski, asking if 10 percent were a "severe enough burden," and a "substantial enough burden" to render the law unconstitutional.

The Wisconsin Constitution in its plain text and as reflected in legal precedents holds a more powerful guarantee of the right to vote than the U.S. Constitution.

In the NAACP, the orals took a more federal direction in jurisprudence, with justices and attorneys citing federal precedents.

Justice Patience D. Roggensack took a strikingly skeptical tone against Clayton Patrick Kawski in referencing all the supporting documentation those without GOP-prescribed ID would have to acquire and spend, sounding incredulous in saying that paying money to the state was necessary to vote. "I'm troubled by having to pay the state to vote," she said. (Marley. MJS)

Justice Michael J. Gableman appeared to this viewer as a vote to uphold the voter ID law.

The Wisconsin Constitution bodes well for pro-voter forces against the Republican Party that has waged a years-long battle against voting, specifically targeting non-GOP demographics.

The pro-voting forces make this point in the Plaintiffs-Respondents-Petitioners' Reply Brief (filed 2/6/14), excerpted below.

Few believe even with a four-to-three GOP majority, the Wisconsin Supreme Court will eviscerate what is the foundation of Wisconsin democracy—the right to vote.

Attorney Pines amplified this argument made in the Plaintiffs-Respondents-Petitioners' Reply Brief:

I. THE VOTER ID LAW HAS THE EFFECT OF DETERMINING I. WHICH QUALIFIED ELECTORS MAY VOTE. THUS, IT IS NOT A LAW THAT  FALLS WITHIN THE LEGISLATURE’S PLENARY AUTHORITY TO ENACT REASONABLE ELECTION REGULATIONS.

A. Because The Legislature Has Limited Constitutional Authority to Regulate “Who” Votes, Defendants Want The Court To Believe That The Voter ID Law Only Regulates “How” Votes Are Cast.

Defendants do not attempt to rebut the League’s argument that the Legislature may not add a qualification to vote, and concede that if the Voter ID law does so, it is unconstitutional. They explicitly concede that the Voter ID law is neither a registration regulation nor a law to implement
the right of suffrage as allowed under Article III, sec. 2.  Brief of Defendants-Appellants (“Def. Br.”) p. 32

Much of the Defendants’ brief is devoted to a discussion of the uncontroverted proposition that the Legislature has plenary authority to enact reasonable election regulations about “when, where and how” elections are conducted. Defendants contend that the law regulates “how ballots are cast” and argue that the Voter ID law is a “reasonable” regulation, no different than a law dictating the form of the ballot or polling hours. Def. Br. pp. 7-16.

Defendants do this because the Wisconsin Supreme Court, for over 150 years, has enforced these basic principles:

  • the Legislature has a limited plenary authority to regulate when, where and how elections are conducted but does not have the plenary authority to determine who may vote, and;  
  • a regulation of when, where and how elections are conducted, if it also touches on who may vote, must not impair or destroy the right to vote.   
Undoubtedly, the Voter ID law determines who may vote. And, even if one were to accept the fanciful notion that the law merely regulates “how” votes are cast, the law is unconstitutional because it impairs the right of qualified electors to vote: 
[Election] regulations are to be subordinate to the enjoyment of the right [to vote],. . . . The right must not be impaired by the regulation. It must be regulation purely, not destruction. If this were not an immutable principle, elements essential to the right itself might be invaded, frittered away, or entirely exscinded, under the name or pretense of regulation . . .  
Dells v. Kennedy, 49 Wis. 555, 6 N.W. 246, 247 (1880) (emphasis added by plaintiff's attorneys)... .

Feb 24, 2014

Wisconsin Voter ID Challenge Hits GOP Law Targeting Who Can Vote

Update: See transcript of GOP-leaning Justice's comment and question: 'I'm troubled by having to pay the state to vote" and Don't "Destroy" the Right to Vote, Say Voting Rights Attorneys.
---
As Scott Walker hides amid the release of emails showing Walker lied, cheated and effectively stole [from the people of Milwaukee County], a major Walker bill targeting citizens voting who Walker perceives to be voting the wrong way will be heard in open court.

Arguments on Wisconsin's Voter ID law are scheduled to be heard by the Supreme Court in the Madison state capitol at 9:45 A.M.; Tuesday, February 25.

WisconsinEye is tentatively scheduled to live stream the arguments on its website online, and on Charter Cable Channel 995 and Time Warner Channel 363.

Wisconsin's Voter ID law remains enjoined by Wisconsin state courts. The state cases to be heard are League of Women Voters of Wisconsin v. Walker and Milwaukee Branch of the NAACP v. Walker.

The Wisconsin Constitution in its plain text and as reflected in legal precedents holds a more powerful guarantee of the right to vote than the U.S. Constitution.

The Wisconsin Constitution bodes well for pro-voter forces against the Republican Party that has waged a years-long battle against voting, specifically targeting non-GOP demographics.

The pro-voting forces make this point in the Plaintiffs-Respondents-Petitioners' Reply Brief (filed 2/6/14), excerpted below.

Few believe even with a four-to-three GOP majority, the Wisconsin Supreme Court will eviscerate what is the foundation of Wisconsin democracy—the right to vote. Look for a 7-0 decision striking down the GOP-crafted law, Act 23.

As Judge Richard Niess wrote in his Decision and Order Granting Summary Declaratory Judgment and Permanent Injunction of Wisconsin Voter ID law on March 12, 2012:

"(A)s a matter of law under the Wisconsin Constitution, sacrificing a qualified elector's right to vote is not a reasonable exercise of the government's prerogative to regulate elections. ... Where does the Wisconsin Constitution say that the government, we, the people, created can simply cast aside the inherent suffrage right of any qualified elector on the wish and promise—even the guarantee—that doing so serves to prevent some unqualified individuals from voting?"

It doesn't. In fact, it unequivocally says the opposite. The right to vote belongs to all Wisconsin citizens who are qualified electors, not just the fortunate majority for whom Act 23 poses little obstacle at the polls."

Plaintiffs-Respondents-Petitioners' Reply Brief:

I. THE VOTER ID LAW HAS THE EFFECT OF DETERMINING I. WHICH QUALIFIED ELECTORS MAY VOTE. THUS, IT IS NOT A LAW THAT  FALLS WITHIN THE LEGISLATURE’S PLENARY AUTHORITY TO ENACT REASONABLE ELECTION REGULATIONS.

A. Because The Legislature Has Limited Constitutional Authority to Regulate “Who” Votes, Defendants Want The Court To Believe That The Voter ID Law Only Regulates “How” Votes Are Cast.

Defendants do not attempt to rebut the League’s argument that the Legislature may not add a qualification to vote, and concede that if the Voter ID law does so, it is unconstitutional. They explicitly concede that the Voter ID law is neither a registration regulation nor a law to implement
the right of suffrage as allowed under Article III, sec. 2.  Brief of Defendants-Appellants (“Def. Br.”) p. 32

Much of the Defendants’ brief is devoted to a discussion of the uncontroverted proposition that the Legislature has plenary authority to enact reasonable election regulations about “when, where and how” elections are conducted. Defendants contend that the law regulates “how ballots are cast” and argue that the Voter ID law is a “reasonable” regulation, no different than a law dictating the form of the ballot or polling hours. Def. Br. pp. 7-16.

Defendants do this because the Wisconsin Supreme Court, for over 150 years, has enforced these basic principles:

  • the Legislature has a limited plenary authority to regulate when, where and how elections are conducted but does not have the plenary authority to determine who may vote, and;  
  • a regulation of when, where and how elections are conducted, if it also touches on who may vote, must not impair or destroy the right to vote.   
Undoubtedly, the Voter ID law determines who may vote. And, even if one were to accept the fanciful notion that the law merely regulates “how” votes are cast, the law is unconstitutional because it impairs the right of qualified electors to vote: 
[Election] regulations are to be subordinate to the enjoyment of the right [to vote],. . . . The right must not be impaired by the regulation. It must be regulation purely, not destruction. If this were not an immutable principle, elements essential to the right itself might be invaded, frittered away, or entirely exscinded, under the name or pretense of regulation . . .  
Dells v. Kennedy, 49 Wis. 555, 6 N.W. 246, 247 (1880) (emphasis added by plaintiff's attorneys)... .

Feb 17, 2014

Suit Against Voter ID Law Hits Obstruction of Military Veterans by GOP

Oh, you're a veteran; 'get lost,' say Republicans
Plaintiff Carl Ellis, a homeless black Milwaukee veteran wants to vote in the future, but if Republicans have their way Ellis and his military service can take a hike because Ellis, in GOP land, has no right to vote!

In an amended post-trial brief in the federal suit Frank v. Walker Post-trial brief challenging Wisconsin's Voter ID Law, civil rights advocates hit Scott Walker and the GOP for "Arbitrarily and Unreasonably Burden(ing) Voting Rights of Veterans ... ."

The amended brief was filed last month.

The brief reads in part:

74
C. Act 23 Arbitrarily and Unreasonably Burdens Voting Rights of Veterans and Technical College Students (Claims/Classes 4 and 6)

Voters are entitled to be free of arbitrary state action, and burdens imposed on the right to vote must be balanced against the asserted state interests.  It is well-settled that arbitrary and therefore “‘invidious’ distinctions cannot be enacted without a violation of the Equal Protection Clause.” Williams v. Rhodes, 393 U.S. 23, 30 (1968).

The burden imposed by Act 23 on veterans and technical college student is simply not  “necessary,” Anderson, 460 U.S. at 789, or justified by any “important regulatory interest[],” Burdick, 504 U.S. at 434. The state has articulated no rational basis, much less a necessary or important interest, for refusing to accept secure photo ID issued by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs when it accepts ID issued by the U.S. military, when both are federal documents with voters’ names and photographs, and when both may lack expiration dates. Similarly, no interest was proffered for seeking to block the use of photo ID from Wisconsin’s two year technical colleges, when those IDs have identical indicia of reliability (name, photo, expiration date within two years from date of issuance) to IDs from other Wisconsin colleges.
1. Act 23 Arbitrarily Excludes the Use of VA ID for Voting (Claim/Class 6) After leaving the military, many veterans receive secure VA IDs, with the veterans’ names and photographs, that are used for matters such as obtaining health care from this federal agency. For years Ellis had only VA ID, and Davis and Newcomb still have only VA ID. States like Indiana allow voters to use VA ID, and Kennedy recommended that Act 23 include VA ID, but the law does not do so. (Sec. I.B.2.)

Act 23’s exclusion of VA ID places severe burdens on veterans who have only VA ID, many of whom, Defendants know, are homeless or marginally housed. (Id.) This includes Ellis, who struggled to get a DMV-issued ID for nearly two years, making numerous trips to multiple agencies to get his birth certificate, and ID. (Sec. I.C.3.) Davis, who is unemployed, and Newcomb, a housekeeper also caring for his children who were involved in a serious accident, have tried but not succeeded in getting DMV-issued ID. (Secs. I.A, I.C.1, I.C.2.a.)

At trial, Defendants articulated no state interest, let alone an “important” one, in refusing to accept this form of secure federal ID. Nor did the State articulate any interest in forcing these veterans to expend time and money obtaining a different photo ID to vote, much less a sufficient interest to justify this burden. See Burdick, 504 U.S. at 434 (citing Anderson, 460 U.S. at 788). In prior briefs, the State hypothesized that the lack of an expiration date on VA ID might justify the exclusion. (Dkt. 38 at 21.) But Act 23 authorizes the use of other forms of photo ID without expiration dates, including some military and tribal ID cards. (Secs. I.B.1.d,e.) It also allows the use of DMV-issued ID with 16-year-old photos. (Sec. I.B.1.a.) Thus the exclusion of VA ID has no evident or articulated purpose other than imposing an unnecessary burden on some veterans, or keeping them from voting. Defendants therefore have violated the Equal Protection Clause.

Wisconsin Voter ID Oral Arguments Set for Feb. 25 Before State High Court

Scott Walker faces a major legal defeat in the likely decision
against the GOP voter suppression law, Wisconsin Act 23
As a federal judge in Milwaukee is writing an opinion on Wisconsin's restrictive Voter ID law after the federal trial held last November, two state civil rights challenges to Wisconsin's Act 23 are set to be heard be heard in oral arguments before the Wisconsin Supreme Court on February 25.

Arguments as scheduled to be heard in the ornate Supreme Court room in the Madison state capitol at 9:45 A.M.; Court room doors open at 9:00 A.M.

WisconsinEye is tentatively scheduled to live stream the arguments on its website online, and on Charter Cable Channel 995 and Time Warner Channel 363.

Wisconsin's Voter ID law also faced a trial in federal court in November 2013.

In federal court, a post-trial brief requesting a federal injunction was filed in December after the trial of two consolidated cases arguing violations of the U.S. Constitution and the Voting Rights Act.

A federal injunction and decision against the Republican Voter ID law are expected, as the November 2013 federal trial is regarded by objective observers as a rout for pro-democratic forces against the GOP voter suppression law.

Wisconsin's Voter ID law also remains enjoined by Wisconsin state courts. The state cases to be heard are League of Women Voters of Wisconsin v. Walker and Milwaukee Branch of the NAACP v. Walker.

The Wisconsin Constitution in its plain text and as reflected in legal precedents holds a much more powerful guarantee of the right to vote than the U.S. Constitution.

Laws that deny the franchise (right to vote) or make voting so difficult and inconvenient that the laws effectively deny the franchise are presumptively unconstitutional under the Wisconsin Constitution.

The Republican Party in Wisconsin designed Act 23 precisely for the purpose of restricting the right to vote, an anti-democratic political tactic repeated across the country in states where the Republicans control both the governor's office and the legislature.

As daily newspapers across Wisconsin have editorially condemned this practice of Republicans, it is expected the GOP-controlled Wisconsin Supreme Court [4-3] will rule against the Republican-enacted Act 23 with so much light focused on the Voter ID case.

Facing defeat against its Act 23, Wisconsin Republicans are fast-tracking an attack on early voting, hoping that few notice what they are doing in the legislature.