In oral arguments today, Judge Diane Wood and Frank Easterbrook both dismissed major elements of two cases cited of the Wisconsin Club for Growth's Eric O'Keefe's attorney and the rationales behind a federal judge's involvement in the Wisconsin John Doe-law enforcement probe of Scott Walker and coordination among Walker, the Walker campaign and third party groups.
Legal scholar Rick Hasen writes a reversal of Judge Rudolph Randa's May 6 ruling halting the probe is likely.
The Randa May 6 ruling can be found here.
Judge Wood challenged the attorney for the rightwing group for whom Randa ruled, "Should a federal court step in and enjoin a state," (57-minute, 50-second of mark of Eric O'Keefe v. John Chisholm (14-1822)) a sentiment and stated skepticism immediately echoed by Judge Easterbrook.
Then, minutes later Easterbrook asked: "Let me tell you what the problem is. If what your client has done is simply not illegal under Wisconsin law at all, why should a federal court issue a [federal] constitutionally based injunction?"
Showing posts with label oral arguments Seventh Circuit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label oral arguments Seventh Circuit. Show all posts
Sep 9, 2014
Reversal Is Likely of Judge Randa's Ruling on John Doe Probe
John Doe Oral Arguments Online at Seventh Circuit Site
Oral arguments of the Eric O'Keefe v. Francis Schmitz and Eric O'Keefe v. John Chisholm cases are available online at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit site.
The three-judge panel hearing the cases is composed of: Judges Frank H. Easterbrook, Diane P. Wood and William J. Bauer.
The three-judge panel hearing the cases is composed of: Judges Frank H. Easterbrook, Diane P. Wood and William J. Bauer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)