Showing posts with label Wisconsin Code of Judicial Ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wisconsin Code of Judicial Ethics. Show all posts

May 30, 2019

Steven Avery Attorney Hits Wisconsin Judge for Constructing Adverse Ruling Against Facts and Law — Awaiting Corrupt Ruling

Madison, Wisconsin — The attorney representing Steven Avery offered a harsh opinion this morning that a presiding circuit court judge is constructing an adverse ruling in an effort to preserve what attorney argues is the wrongful conviction of Avery, featured in the Emmy-winning Making a Murderer.

Kathleen Zellner writes in Twitter: "The lower court is facing the impossible task of constructing an adverse ruling that will not be reversed by the higher court. The facts and clearcut laws will be the wrecking ball of this house of cards. Time to do the right thing for Steven Avery."
Advocates for Steven Avery are growing angry at what appears to be the corrupt effort by Sheboygan County Judge Angela W. Sutkiewicz (substituting) who apparently reached a result adverse to Steven Avery in State v. Steven A. Avery, Appeal Number 2017AP002288 long ago.

But Sutkiewicz works backwards. Result first, then draft an order and opinion to support the position of corrupt Wisconsin law enforcement, an opinion that will, law enforcement and Sutkiewicz believe, prevail in appellate court for a time — a delaying tactic.

The prosecution led by Attorney General Joshua Kaul (D) is employing the legal services of corrupt state attorneys including Mark Williams, Asst Attorney General and Special Prosecutor Thomas J. Fallon, and Special Prosecutor Norman Gahn.

Fallon and Gahn do not challenge the oft-repeated fact that the two corrupt jurists not only worked together to illegally destroy evidence, the two DoJ attorneys now write legal filings opposing Zellner's March 11 call for a reversal or new trial in post-conviction litigation.

Before Zellner won her motion for a remand (sending back) the case to circuit court, Zellner argued in her Feb. 1 legal filing:

The [State] ... conveys an attitude of impunity for its past actions of withholding exculpatory evidence and its current action of continuing the concealment of its destruction of potentially exculpatory or useful evidence. ...

Kahl, Ken Kratz, Mark Williams, Thomas J. Fallon, and Norman Gahn. This is Wisconsin law enforcement. And Angela W. Sutkiewicz is the Wisconsin judiciary.

Fallon and Gahn argue that the evidence they help destroy was "inexplicably released" in their  March 29, 2019 legal filing, (p 13).

In its late-March legal filing, the DoJ argues procedural objections to Avery's charges of bad-faith evidence destruction, deceit, concealment and deception, all of which present Due Process questions, (Steven Avery legal filings; #Work with KZ, WBAY, WLUK).

The deception of the DoJ attorneys veered into another spectacle in February when state attorney Mark Williams left a Feb errant voicemail message to Thomas Fallon on Zellner's phone, plotting how to mislead Zellner.

May 8, 2019

Wisconsin Attorney General Joshua Kaul Is Promoting a 'Mockery of Justice' in Making a Murderer Case

Above, attorney Kathleen Zellner is shown walking with
innocent people for whom she and her legal team have won
exoneration and freedom. The world-renown attorney
faces perhaps her biggest challenge yet against corrupt
Wisconsin law enforcement, and a state judiciary hostile
to civil rights and stacked with corrupt jurists biased in favor
of police. Zellner has won a worldwide following of
admirers
who object to the imprisonment of people known
to be innocent.

Innocent awaits ruling from corrupt county circuit court


Madison, Wisconsin — A wrongfully convicted man, Steven Avery, is awaiting a state circuit court ruling on his motion for an evidentiary hearing, and a new trial.

The Feb 25, 2019 appellate court order mandating "any proceedings necessary to address [Avery's] claims" points to a hearing after briefing at the circuit court to which the case had been sent back.

No such proceedings have been ordered to this date.
 ---
Steven Avery's story is abject demonstration of the determination of law enforcement to work against innocents, and the incapacity of Wisconsin society — corporate media, police, courts, bureaucracies, elected representatives and many citizens — to even acknowledge the perverse efforts of the Wisconsin Dept of Justice (DoJ) now led by Attorney General Joshua Kaul (D), to keep innocents in prison.

Kaul is working to shield criminal acts committed by Wisconsin law enforcement by blocking examination of evidence, opposing all court hearings, and promoting "finality in criminal litigation" so that police and prosecutorial misconduct are protected, and the innocent remain imprisoned, (p.4. State's Response to Defendant's Motion for New Trial Based on Alleged Youngblood Violation, March 29, 2019).

Steven Avery is featured in the Emmy-winning documentary, Making a Murderer.

Kaul has the discretion to accede to Avery's requests for transparency and open examination of evidence and state misconduct.

The case is now before Sheboygan County Judge Angela W. Sutkiewicz who is expected to issue a ruling within weeks on Avery's legal motions. 

Sutkiewicz is a corrupt judge who does the work of police and prosecutors against people and the cause of truth.

Advocates for truth in the Avery case expect their efforts to be won in state appellate court after an anticipated adverse ruling by Sutkiewicz.

The post-conviction ligation is State v. Steven A. Avery, Appeal Number 2017AP002288, now before Manitowoc County Circuit Court, substituted by Sutkiewicz.

State of Wisconsin Criminality 

In its late-March legal filing, the DoJ argues only procedural objections to Avery's charges of bad-faith state evidence destruction, deceit, concealment and deception, all of which present Due Process questions, (Steven Avery legal filings; #Work with KZ, WBAY, WLUK).

Continuing its strategy of avoiding mention of charged state criminality and lawlessness in litigation, the State's conduct is striking in its avoidance of the merits of Avery's charges that the Calumet County Sheriff's Office secretly transferred evidence, the remains of a murder victim, Teresa Halbach, to private custody in 2011, in violation of state statutes that govern preservation of physical evidence collected; among other allegations.

Commenting on the State's March 29, 2019 legal filing in Newsweek Magazine, Avery's post-conviction attorney, Kathleen Zellner, said:

Wisconsin Dept of Justice is painting itself into a corner
in its effort to keep innocent men in prison. "The State
is thumbing its nose at the appellate court once again,"
wrongful conviction attorney Kathleen Zellner told Newsweek
on April 2. "That court specifically ordered that the merits of the
alleged bone destruction be addressed. Rather than follow the
court's directive, the State has constructed a convoluted
procedural argument that defies logic or precedent."
'Of course the State cannot address the merits of Avery's claim, because it is blatantly guilty of evidence destruction. Its charade continues without the slightest inclination to discover the truth. Significantly, one of the culprits in the whole sad scenario authored the State's Response. Unfortunately, the citizens of Wisconsin are the recipients of this mockery of justice.'

Zellner refers to the DoJ post-conviction litigation team and Thomas Fallon, who helped oversee the decision to return the alleged human bones to the Halbach family. Fallon wrote the state’s response, and is defending his own misconduct.

The post-conviction ligation is State v. Steven A. Avery, (Appeal Number 2017AP002288), now before Manitowoc County Circuit Court.

Before Zellner won her motion for a remand (sending back) the case to Circuit Court, Zellner and other advocates for the innocent Avery argued in her Feb. 1 legal filing:

Mar 4, 2019

Steven Avery Supporters Want Sheboygan County Judge off Case — Cite Conflicts, Bias


Updated - Madison, Wisconsin—Supporters of the wrongfully convicted Steven Avery want Sheboygan County Judge Angela W. Sutkiewicz to step aside from the case on which she has a conflict of interest, and is operating in apparent violation of the Wisconsin Code of Judicial Ethics.

Concern that Sutkiewicz is hostile to Avery's post-conviction litigation has caused supporters to begin a petition last weekend, that quickly garnered over 10,000 signatures calling for Sutkiewicz to remove herself from the case, and asking for support from Gov Tony Evers (D).

Judge Sutkiewicz began hearing Avery's post-conviction litigation in 2013 after Manitowoc County Judge Patrick Willis retired in 2012.

In Making a Murderer, season 2, (episode two, 42:51-minute mark), Avery said he "had a problem with [Sutkiewicz] before," recounting that his post-conviction litigation was heard by Sutkiewicz in 2013.

Sutkiewicz was simultaneously presiding over Avery's post-conviction litigation and murder victim's Teresa Halbach's wrongful death suit against Avery in 2013 (Manitowoc County Case Number 2006CV000150 Teresa M Halbach Estate et al vs. Steven A Avery et al.).

Notes Avery: "I thought maybe it, [post-conviction litigation], would go to a different judge, she got them both."

Sutkiewicz held open the Halbach-Avery civil litigation for some 15 months after the Halbach estate requested a voluntary dismissal in November 2013, in an apparent bid to goad the plaintiff into seeking settlement monies from Avery.

In 2015, Avery sent a letter to the court inquiring about the status of the civil suit following the Notice of Motion for (Plaintiff's) Voluntary Dismissal hearing of November 21, 2013. Avery also appealed his post-conviction litigation to state appellate court complaining about Sutkiewicz' conduct in both cases. Sutkiewicz then dismissed the civil litigation in April 2015.

The Wisconsin Code of Judicial Conduct demands that judges "shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary" (SCR 60.03 A judge shall avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety in all of the judge's activities).

That Sutkiewicz acted in contravention of the Code of Judicial Conduct appears apparent.

Additionally, the Code of Judicial Conduct mandates:

SCR 60.03 (2)  A judge may not allow family, social, political or other relationships to influence the judge's judicial conduct or judgment.  A judge may not lend the prestige of judicial office to advance the private interests of the judge or of others or convey or permit others to convey the impression that they are in a special position to influence the judge. ...
Sutkiewicz' conduct in which she heard two Avery cases, Sutkiewicz acted in accordance with her oft-stated wish that courts act as victims' advocates, to the point of compromising the rights of the accused and the convicted.

Next step: Judge Sutkiewicz will hold a hearing in late April in which numerous law enforcement and prosecutors suspected of misconduct will be compelled to testify in a public hearing (Mal Contends, Ferak).

Sutkiewicz is under fire and very public scrutiny.

Notes John Ferak in an interview with Avery post-conviction attorney, Kathleen Zellner:

2. What can people expect to happen in Steven's case over the next 60 to 90 days?

Zellner response: In the next 60 days the circuit court will rule on whether Mr. Avery's conviction should be reversed. The judge, Angela Sutkiewicz, should recuse herself from the case since she has a blatant conflict of interest. She has presided over the Halbach wrongful death case and Avery's post-conviction case. This is totally improper and she should recuse herself as Judge (Willis) did. If she will not, Avery fully expects her to rule against him as she has on every issue to date. She should be holding an evidentiary hearing but it is doubtful she will. The appellate court will reverse her for all of her blatant errors.

Sutkiewicz substitutes her affinity for prosecutors in place of neutral adjudication. To be accused means you have no rights, to be convicted means law enforcement can do no wrong, in what passes for Sutkiewicz' legal mind in Wisconsin.

In 2017, Sutkiewicz rejected Steven Avery's request for a trial made through his post-conviction attorney, Kathleen Zellner.

Sutkiewicz issued her ruling and opinion without ordering and conducting an evidentiary hearing on Kathleen Zellner's 1,200-page post-conviction motion, replete with expert forensic testimony and analyses.

"The judge criticized the defense conclusions as 'speculative' and based on 'interim opinions' by experts," notes Heavy. com.

Few observers believe Sutkiewicz is equipped with the competence to adjudge world-renown forensic scientific evidence.

On June 14, 2018, Avery through Zellner filed a motion for judicial substitution of Sutkiewicz, (Fox-11, Digital). The state objected to the motion for a new judge (Fox-11 News).
---
"When a judge determines that, for any reason, he or she cannot, or it appears he or she cannot, act in an impartial manner," a judge must disqualify herself, reads Wisconsin statute,757.19.

Asks a UK Avery supporter, "why is Sutkiewicz still on this case?"