Showing posts with label U.S. Senate filibuster. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. Senate filibuster. Show all posts

Nov 22, 2013

U.S. Senate: Up-or-Down Vote and Majority Rules for Pres Appointees

Village Voice - January, 20 2010
On January, 20 2010 Roy Edroso wrote a piece in the Village Voice under the headline:

Scott Brown Wins Mass. Race, Giving GOP 41-59 Majority in the Senate

Edroso was right because the U.S. Senate makes its own ridiculous rules under Article 1, Section 5 of Constitution and the minority of 41 senators did have power to defeat the will of the 59 senators.

It's like a City Council meeting voting on a resolution: Resolution has nine Ayes, and two Nyes; resolution is defeated.

The rules are idiotic, something you might find in some far-away, corrupt regime without an appreciation for democratic values.

No appreciation for democratic values, yes, it's around.

One does not have to look too far: Look at Washington D.C., our nation's capitol, where the U.S. Senate and the U.S. House comprise the legislative branch.

Throw in a crazy political party, the Republicans, into the mix and catastrophe is guaranteed.

Yesterday, Harry Reid and Democratic senators decided that executive branch appointees and nominees for federal judgeships can now get an Up-or-Down vote, and if an appointee gets the most votes of sitting senators, she has won confirmation.

Legislation and nominees to the U.S. Supreme Court still face filibusters in the Senate.

Roy Edroso should write a new piece: U.S. Senate Still World's Most Dumbfounded Body.

Dec 29, 2010

Filibuster Could Be Dead in a Week

The bone-headed [but great for big-moneyed lobbyists and their Senator servants] U.S. Senate procedure known roughly as the 'filibuster' could soon be sent the way of John McCain's run for the presidency. The filibuster—where 41 votes beats 59 votes—is undemocratic and represents perfectly the non-sensical ways of the U.S. Senate.

Above right is a photo of Mississippi Senator Theodore Bilbo who filibustered a 1938 anti-lynching bill to protect "Saxon civilization" (Courtesy Library of Congress).

From the Democratic Strategist:

On January 5th, it appears that a majority of the Senate will vote to change its rules, barring unforeseen GOP shenanigans, followed by another vote in which a majority of senators vote to reform the filibuster. The reason it seems like a done deal one week out is that all 53 returning Democratic senators have signed on a letter urging Majority Leader Reid to take up filibuster reform on that day, and they are not likely to settle for anything that preserves the status quo.

It is possible that some kind of weak compromise will keep the filibuster functionally alive, but crippled. But it is quite possible that Dems are ready to shred it, given the damage it has done and the way it has been abused by Republicans. Katrina vanden Heuval explains it exceptionally-well in her Washington Post op-ed:


...Back when Lyndon Johnson was majority leader in the Senate, he needed to file for cloture to end a filibuster only once. During President Obama's first two years, Harry Reid filed for cloture 84 times. To put that in perspective, the filibuster was used more in 2009 than in the 1950s and 1960s combined.Even as we acknowledge the progress we've made these past two years, we must never forget the policies that lie dead on the Senate floor at the hands of the filibuster. We got a Recovery Act, but a filibuster prevented it from being sufficiently large. We got health-care reform, but a filibuster killed the public option. We got Wall Street reform, but a filibuster killed provisions to break up the big banks. We got an extension of unemployment benefits, a payroll tax cut and more, but the threat of the filibuster killed our chances to do that without giving handouts to the wealthy.

.... The filibuster was never intended to be wielded as a weapon of obstruction. Its current abuse was not contemplated by those who created it. Used this way, the filibuster does not just check the power of the majority; it cripples it. It is the very definition of minority tyranny, a concept as antithetical to democratic principles as any in the republic.

Katrina vanden Heuval then nails the case that now is the time to put a stop to it:


There is only one day in the year when the Senate can make changes to its rules without the fear of that process, itself, being filibustered - and that day is fast approaching. Jan. 5, 2011, will be the first day of the 112th Congress and, as such, the only day where a simple majority can vote to change the Senate rules (on all other days, 67 votes would be required)......The chances for reforming the filibuster may be the best in a generation.

And while it is unclear at the moment exactly which of the reforms proposed by Democratic Senators will be implemented, all of them are designed to end the present tryanny of the GOP minority, as vanden Heuval explains:


The options they offer are simple and unquestionably reasonable. Sens. Udall and Merkley have put forward what has become known as the "constitutional option," a basic two-step process in which 51 senators first agree to adopt new rules, and then 51 senators agree on a reform package. Their package probably would not end the filibuster altogether. But it wouldn't need to. Procedural changes - such as preventing a filibuster on the motion to proceed, shortening the amount of debate allowed between cloture motions and ending the unconscionable practice of anonymous holds - have the potential to remake the Senate.These reforms would prevent a single senator from wielding the filibuster against the entire body and would allow the majority to challenge the minority without wasting precious floor time. Perhaps most important, the act of revising the rules in response to abuse may in itself serve as a check on the minority, a warning that the overreach of the type the GOP perfected during the 111th Congress will not be tolerated in the future.
If everything goes according to plan, we'll have to redefine the GOP acronym meaning from "Gridlock, Obstruction and Paralysis," at least for senate Republicans, to something like..."Game Over, Pachyderms."

Feb 6, 2010

US Senate Defends Doing Nothing

In the United States Senate, doing nothing is protected as a point of historical pride. It is the privilege of a U.S. Senator to do nothing and the do-nothing gang does not want this august legislative body to lose its harrowed privilege.

As Gail Collins puts it this morning: "There is a stupendous lack of real enthusiasm in the Senate for doing anything as dramatic as eliminating the senators’ right to stop things."

“It’s beyond the breaking point,” said Senator Tom Harkin, referring to the U.S. Senate's obstruction-as-usual, holds on nominations, filibusters, the whole paralysis of a sick legislative body. Harkin will introduce a bill to eliminate the Senate filibuster next week.

Even reformers like Sen. Russ Feingold defend the filibuster. Maybe Feingold and the Senate will have a change a heart, feeling that the problems facing Americans are so serious that a decaying institution's relics and undemocratic rules must change for the good of the citizens of our republic.

Will Feingold's GOP opponents this year, Terrence Wall and Dave Westlake [who otherwise do not stand a chance], challenge Feingold's on his defense of doing nothing? That would be ironic as the GOP employs the filibuster so often in its attempt to see the Senate do nothing. Even more ironic as the Senate Democrats are the GOP's allies is preserving this tool of obstruction.

Nothing like arming your opponents in defense of an undemocratic body. Welcome to the Democratic Party. Maybe the Democrats will finally kill the filibuster.

And then maybe the Republican Party will come out in favor of teaching evolution, and empowering the rights of American citizens [even black people] to vote, slash the American empire and slap the military-industrial complex. Right.

-via mal contends

Feb 4, 2010

Russ Feingold's Corner of Madness

Update: Please note response of the office of Sen. Feingold in the comments section.

George Wagner's MJS column last month reporting Sen. Russ Feingold defended the filibuster at a listening session in Milwaukee reveals a problem of Feingold's that progressives know about but rarely speak: What Bertrand Russell would describe as Feingold's "corner of madness."

That would be Feingold's tendency to take utterly insupportable positions in the name of polishing his brand as a political maverick. Certainly, it's not Feingold's intellect that leads him to the absurd.

Examples:

- Defending the filibuster in the name of deliberation
- Voting for the confirmation of Chief Justice John Roberts because Roberts assured the Judiciary Committee that he was committed to the jurisprudence of an "umpire" and not that a rightwing activist, Roberts' past ideology apparently notwithstanding in Feingold's mind

Feingold has accomplished much in his tenure in the Senate, but he will never be a great Senator like Robert M. LaFollette because of his tendency to veer into the political idiosyncratic and irrational.

One can go on: Feingold's fighting against retraining funds for out-of-work Janesville autoworkers, raving against stimulus spending in the middle of the worst recession since the Great Depression, supporting the Republican crazies in the impeachment of Bill Clinton and other nonsense.

Liberals [Emily Mills, for example] won't call Feingold out on these preposterous positions because of Feingold's lonely voice of opposition to the worst of the Bush-Cheney nightmare.

But if Feingold's views had prevailed, we would have Senate obstruction, an ultra-activist Roberts Court, out-of-work Americans in need of training, and an insufficiently large fiscal stimulus ... . Ohhh, yeah. This is the type of maverick whom Sarah Palin supports, and Feingold knows this to be true so, really: Knock it off, man.

Dec 21, 2009

Krugman: Kill the Filibuster

Putting aside the notion now pushed by Republicans that policy such as health care reform [vis a vis say war] must have overwhelming, super-majority support before it can legitimately be passed into law and sustained as public policy, the Republicans and tacitly most Democrats support anti-democratic, dangerous legislative procedures choking off the will of the American people.

The most pernicious is the U.S. Senate filibuster, and its abolition is a reform needed, as Paul Krugman writes, "unless you want the nation to sit motionless, with an effectively paralyzed government, waiting for financial, environmental and fiscal crises to strike."

Will Senate majority leader Harry Reid listen to these concerns? Does Harry Reid think?