Showing posts with label Supreme Court Justice Patience Roggensack. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court Justice Patience Roggensack. Show all posts

May 22, 2015

GOP's Court Allies Try to Jam Through Scott Walker-John Doe Cases in Violation of Court Rules

Need more evidence the fix is in for Scott Walker's and allies trying to abort a law enforcement investigation by state constitutional officers of both parties?

Patrick Marley has the story breaking at the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel on three cases at the Wisconsin Supreme Court that were not on the Court calendar and that the GOP's Justice Roggensack wants heard anyway, in violation of Court rules.

The three cases heard are not named, hence not necessarily the John Doe cases in which Walker and his allies are trying to evade being investigated, but most observers are guessing Roggensack is still fronting for Walker for the three John Doe cases.

In a related story, see Pema Levy's piece today at Mother Jones: How Scott Walker and His Allies Hijacked the Wisconsin Supreme Court - And what it means for the probe into alleged campaign violations by Walker and conservative dark-money groups.

The bottom line: Even investigating Scott Walker's clear violations of state law are blocked by corrupt Republicans on the bench.

Notes Brendan Fischer at PRWatch:

In last year's Supreme Court race, WMC spent an estimated $500,000 supporting Justice Roggensack's reelection, and Wisconsin Club for Growth spent $350,000. Together they outspent the $652,318 spent by the justice's own campaign.

WMC issued a special Supreme Court edition of its "Business Voice" magazine in advance of the election, with page after page warning that if Roggensack were to lose, "all of the reforms of Governor Scott Walker and the business community would hang in the balance." WMC's president described the group's efforts to "elect 'strict constructionist' judges to the high court," and Justice Ziegler penned an op-ed endorsing Roggensack.

Roggensack refuses to recuse from hearing WiCFG and John Doe cases despite the clear conflict of interest in secretly hearing cases involving parties who elected her.

Mar 31, 2013

Jake at Kos Crunches Wisconsin Supreme Court Numbers

Jake formerly of the LP, at Daily Kos crunches the numbers on the Wisconsin Supreme Court race this-coming Tuesday.

Two thoughts after reading Jake's numbers, assuming other factors:

One is I doubt there will be the crushing margins that Scott Walker gave Tom Barrett in the northeast and central Wisconsin counties in June 2012. Not only do the GOP forces not have $70-million-plus to spend on a state the size of Wisconsin as in the Recall election, the GOP's Roggensack will not get the benefit of the anti-recall vote phenomenon.

Secondly, Milwaukee and the southeast need to turn out. I know, this is obvious.

So, can the Fallone turn-out operation do the job? We'll soon know.

Every religious-minded, black-hating, gun-loving, worker-despising Wisconsin citizen will be hearing a lot from the GOP the next two days.

Mar 27, 2013

Justice Pat Roggensack Lists Sheriff Who Negligently Incarcerated Freed, Innocent Man

Joseph "Joey" Awe - Another
innocent man goes free. Imprisoned by
negligent law enforcement and
corrupt District Attorney.
Innocents Incarcerated and Freed Show Inappropriate Use of Police Images in Supreme Court Campaigns

Updated - Take a look at Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Pat Roggensack's endorsements on her website and a reader will find one Sheriff Kim Gaffney of Marquette County.

But Kim Gaffney, Marquette County Sheriff (1975-present), is responsible, along with the past Marquette County DA [then-Marquette County District Attorney Richard Dufour (2006)], for putting an innocent man behind bars (for arson)—a common occurrence in the American prison-industrial complex.

Joseph "Joey" Awe was convicted in September 2006 because Gaffney and the insurance company (Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company) could not find an explanation for a fire that began in the electrical service panel of a 130-year-old building.

The Sheriff and DA blamed Mr. Awe; and the insurance company saved money from having to pay a policy, and Sheriff Gaffney got to fly the flag of law-and-order, after a Sheriff's investigator conducted only one interview with Awe.

They—Sheriff Gaffney, the DA and Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company—relied on the discredited practice on "negative corpus," concluding the fire must be intentional because no cause was found.

No evidence implicated Awe.

Wonder if Gaffney will issue an apology.

The innocent Awe spent three years behind bars before a judge ordered his release from incarceration.

The Wisconsin State Journal's Dee Hall deserves special recognition for digging into the case and her superlative investigative reporting throughout this case. Said Awe, "I don't think I would be where I am now (free) if it weren't for (the State Journal). I know I wouldn't."

As Justice Pat Roggensack proudly lists Sheriff Gaffney's name on her endorsements page, one wonders if Rogeensack will renounce Sheriff Gaffney and remove her name from her campaign.

The problem with listing law enforcement officials generally in a run for judge is the presumption that the police and the DA's office are always right and righteous. Nothing could be further from the truth; talk to the folks at your local Innocence Project.

In any event, we have the images of righteousness, goodness and rectitude conveyed through law enforcement and appropriated by political campaigns for the Wisconsin Supreme Court, though any jurist knows perfectly well that due process, impartiality and the rule-of-law demand that no class of litigants—not defendants, not campaign contributors, not law enforcement, not the DA's offices—deserve a superior place in a judge's consideration of a legal case, emphatically in the state's highest court of the land.

Justice Pat Roggensack clearly holds a different opinion.
---
We have written before, 'Don’t worry about the result; just tell me what the law is.'

Such a directive ought to be the mission, objective and goal of every candidate to the justice of the state’s top appellate court, the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

If one were to ask candidates for the Wisconsin Supreme Court their commitment to the above principle, one can expect a declaration of absolute fidelity.

But you would not deduce the presence of this judicial ethos from the campaign of Pat Roggensack.

Like the others' before her, her campaign does not offer explanation of the judicial process, the nature of appellate procedures, the role of briefs and arguments in the creation of judicial policy, and the imperative to be impartial; but rather well-crafted political demagoguery.

Now, one can read about the endorsements from police associations, law enforcement officials, and District Attorneys.

What does parading these endorsements mean?

That Pat Roggensack has a disposition in favor of a particular class of litigants?

Judges are supposed to be impartial.

Roggensack should stow the likes of the law-and-order, we’re-tough rhetoric, and instead edify the electorate on the judicial processes, the function of the top appellate court in impartially ascertaining what the law is, and the candidates' ability and dedication to this enterprise.

Electing judges whose job it is to avoid advocacy once in office ought to result in the candidates' insulating themselves from specific communities of interest during the campaign, especailly the likes of Sheriff Kim Gaffney.

Mar 2, 2013

Club for Growth Filling WMC's Decreased Role in Supreme Court Race

Wisconsin Supreme Court - Crooked as a dog's hind leg
Update II: See Report: Madison needs to build over 1,000 rental units each year to keep up with demand (Godar, The Capital Times)

Update: Rule-of-law candidate, Ed Fallone, says he'll reverse conflict-of-interest rule written by the Wisconsin Realtors Association and the business lobbying group. Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce.

Judith 'Judy' Faulkner is the embodiment of the American Dream.

A brilliant woman who worked her ass off at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Faulkner wrote computer code assisting medical professionals in tracking patient information.

Reportedly a woman of wide-ranging interests, the former student in the psychiatry department at UW-Madison constantly innovated her computer software, took it to the private sector and later became the founder and CEO of the giant Epic Systems Corp. of Verona, Wisconsin. [Note: Some two years ago, it was announced that Epic is going to build a huge auditorium on its Verona site. As a result, now, sources tell me the downtown condo market in Madison is finally beginning to flourish, vis a vis just three years ago in 2010. Word is new, prospective Epic employees will simply commute to Verona and live in downtown Madison and the Isthmus, and are driving the market.]

Thank you, Judy Faulkner.

One question Ms. Faulkner encountered in Wisconsin is why the Wisconsin Manufactures and Commerce (WMC) sought to create a corrupt Wisconsin Supreme Court that would rubber-stamp the position of the increasingly right-wing and misogynistic Wisconsin Republican Party.

Why exactly is WMC necessarily an adjunct of the GOP and why is WMC spending some $1.8 million to install Michael Gableman to the Supreme Court like it did in 2008?

For no good cause, Faulkner apparently reasoned.

Faulkner, noting what writer, Peter Gruett described as Wisconsin's "slide toward reactionary social and fiscal policies," decided to pull Epic's business from local vendors and contractors who support WMC's bid to take over Wisconsin government, as reported by WMC Watch. [One also wonders why the Wisconsin Restaurant Association similarly supports reactionary social and fiscal policies; why running a restuarant means a woman's right to choose should no longer exist? But that's another story.]

Now, one of the four corrupt GOP justices, Justice Patience Roggensack, is running for reelection. And the WMC News page is unusually silent on the race.

But the Wisconsin Club For Growth is filling in where WMC begged out.

Reads an e-mail from United Wisconsin:

Wisconsin Club For Growth, the ultra right-wing front group funded through shady channels by wealthy billionaires like the Koch brothers, has nearly tripled their investment in Justice Roggensack's reelection.

This week, the non-partisan Brennan Center for Justice reported that since the primary, the group has spent $300,000 on TV commercials alone! You see, groups like Club For Growth know that to ensure Walker's most extreme policy overreaches get a less-than fair hearing on the court, they need to maintain the status-quo by keeping the Wisconsin Supreme Court stacked with partisan judges like Roggensack.
Prof. Ed Fallone has a tough election in just one month on April 2.

The Brennan Center also notes, "In 2011, special interest groups set a new record, spending just under $3.6 million on television ads in a race that many groups sought to recast as a referendum on Governor Scott Walker. Wisconsin will likely continue to see high spending by outside groups this year."

One hopes that, like Faulkner, voters conclude there is no cause for the Wisconsin Supreme Court to function as a reactionary and corrupt institution.

One imperative is Fallone telling voters of this reality over and over.

Feb 21, 2013

Roggensack's Obstruction of Assault against Colleague Strikes Chord

Cover-up of attack continues
Justice Pat Roggensack's run for re-election came up in a topic among several women meeting for breakfast near Madison recently.

The women—professional, educated, and liberal in political sensibility but not political junkies—were most reportedly offended not by Roggensack's embrace of the Republican Party's agenda and the GOP justices' decimation of Wisconsin's Open Meetings Law. Unfortunate, but true; they didn't really know much about GOP corruption.

What offended them was Roggensack's obstruction of holding David Prosser accountable for actually choking a fellow justice on June 13, 2011.

The choking incident was first reported by Bill Lueders, writing for the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism on June 25, 2011.

Holding Prosser accountable for physically attacking a woman in the workplace appears to be a no-brainer.

But Roggensack, along with Prosser's other two GOP colleagues, decided to block the recommendation of willful violations of ethics by the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, since packed with GOP partisans by Scott Walker.

Prosser attacks a female colleague and Roggensack covers up the crime by a sitting Wisconsin Supreme Court justice.

One hopes this would be seen by voters as an unforgiveable betrayal by Roggensack and her other GOP cohorts.

Feb 20, 2013

Rule of Law v. GOP Corruption

Rule of law v. corruption. An easy choice for the 20 (maybe 30ish)-some percent of the electorate who will vote on April 2.

Marquette University law professor Ed Fallone faces Wisconsin state Supreme Court Justice Patience Roggensack in the April 2 general election.

This is a race where the sitting Justice Roggensack is a corrupt partisan, and should be described as such by Prof. Fallone, a thoughtful academic and jurist.

Roggensack already has rightwing money from Wisconsin Club for Growth hitting the air waves, and state and county GOP officials are kicking in.

Fallone will be outspent by Roggensack.

Fallone should tell the truth in this race—if for no other reason than truth in politics is needed in democracies—that Roggensack is a corrupt partisan.

Fact is Fallone cannot afford not to tell this truth, so he ought to sing it out loudly.

Wisconsin needs Fallone to tell the truth; because voters won't get the truth on this race from broadcast media, Gannett Co. Inc.'s 13 newspapers or the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel and Wisconsin State Journal.

As we have noted here before, Fallone should also educate the public about what the state's top appellate court does. Few voters know.

And he needs to make fidelity to "the absence of bias or prejudice in favor of, or against, particular parties, or classes of parties, as well as maintaining an open mind in considering issues that may come before the judge," the basis upon which Fallone is running for Supreme Court justice, as the Wisconsin's Code of Judicial Conduct mandates.

The Republican Party wants the Wisconsin Supreme Court as a partisan instrument, packed with partisans as Scott Walker has accomplished with the Wisconsin Judicial Commission that had the audacity to police a Republican justice's ethics.

Rule of law v. corruption. An easy choice for the 20 (maybe 30ish)-some percent of the electorate who will vote on April 2.

Jan 8, 2013

Supreme Court Race Should Focus on Rule of Law

"A reasoned, accurate explanation is not an inconsequential nicety that this court may disregard for the sake of convenience or haste. It is the cornerstone of the legitimacy of judicial decision-making. ... In hastily reaching judgment, Justice Patience D. Roggensack, Justice Annette K. Ziegler, and Justice Michael J. Gableman author an order, joined by Justice David T. Prosser, lacking a reasoned, transparent analysis and incorporating numerous errors of law and fact. This kind of order seems to open the court unnecessarily to the charge that the majority has reached a pre-determined conclusion not based on the facts and the law, which undermines the majority's ultimate decision."
- Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson dissenting in Ozanne v. Ftizgerald, Fitzgerald, Ellis and Suder, Defendents, La Follette, Defendent-Petitioner-Movant. [Wisconsin and Wisconsin ex rel., Huebsch, Petitioners v. Sumi et al, Defendants (June 14, 2011)] Case effectively invalidated Wisconsin's Open Meeting law and upheld Scott Walker secretly-contrived, anti-worker-organizing Act 10 passed with unanimous GOP support and unanimous Democratic opposition.

Madison, Wisconsin -- Two challengers are slated to run against Wisconsin state Supreme Court Justice Patience Roggensack—Marquette University law professor Ed Fallone and well-regarded, lemon law attorney Vince Megna.
Justice Roggensack is one of the corrupt four on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, believing as her Republican colleague David Prosser does that her votes on the Court are to serve Republican constituencies and the GOP.

When Prosser was running for reelection last in March 2011, Prosser campaigned openly telling special interests how his past votes advanced their interests, not even bothering to declare himself an impartial jurist ascertaining the law and impartially applying it to cases that come before the state's top appellate court.

Roggensack will be somewhat more circumspect in her campaign, though as Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson in the infamous Open Meeting-Worker Organizing case at the top of this piece, suggested: GOP justices reach pre-determined conclusions on political cases.

We can count on Roggensack, though, to message her campaign with clear displays of affinity with specific communities of interest and certain classes of litigants. 'I'll vote with these guys (the GOP),' is the message.

This message is an implicit admission of corruption.

The job of a Supreme Court justice is to act as an impartial judge seeking to find out what the law is and how the law applies to cases that come before the state's top appellate court.That's not a controversial assertion; it's fundamental to our judicial branch.

As the Wisconsin's Code of Judicial Conduct mandates; "'impartiality' (means) the absence of bias or prejudice in favor of, or against, particular parties, or classes of parties, as well as maintaining an open mind in considering issues that may come before the judge."

In the last 20 years in Wisconsin, I have seen only two state Supreme Court campaigns emphasizing the rule of law and impartiality—those of former Assistant Attorney General JoAnne Kloppenburg, and Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson.

We have no culture of good government towards our judicial branch nor in our greater political culture—not from the corporate press, not from academia, not from judicial candidates generally—so it no wonder that corrupt partisans such as Justices  Roggensack, Ziegler, Gableman and Prosser get elected with turn-out generally in the 20-some percent range or less. [Prosser's narrow 2011 win over Kloppenburg with some 33 percent turn-out is an outlier.]

One can understand why some advocate "merit selection,' though this is short-sighted and foolish, in my opinion: I mean how can a partisan governor and partisan legislature be counted on to appoint impartial judges? How could a non-partisan panel appointing justices be ascertained?

Some suggestions for the candidates:
  • Educate the public about what the top appellate court does. Few voters have a faint clue
  • Make fidelity to "the absence of bias or prejudice in favor of, or against, particular parties, or classes of parties, as well as maintaining an open mind in considering issues that may come before the judge" the basis upon why you are running for Supreme Court justice